Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

Options

politicalbetting.com » Blog Archive » Unelected PM Boris Johnson maintains his 100% record in Parlia

13567

Comments

  • Options

    Scott_P said:
    Penrith and Borders: Independent Conservative GAIN from Conservative.
    Not likely as a 55% leave seat. The only possibility if Lib/Lab stand down and give him a free run
  • Options
    GallowgateGallowgate Posts: 19,079
    The Sun front page is just comical.
  • Options
    GallowgateGallowgate Posts: 19,079

    Scott_P said:
    Penrith and Borders: Independent Conservative GAIN from Conservative.
    Not likely as a 55% leave seat. The only possibility if Lib/Lab stand down and give him a free run
    Which is entirely possible.
  • Options
    HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 116,991

    HYUFD said:

    MaxPB said:

    HYUFD said:

    MaxPB said:

    HYUFD said:

    MaxPB said:

    MaxPB said:

    MaxPB said:

    Hmm, it's going to be tough for Labour to use the unelected insult against Boris any more.

    I think them turning down an election will play very poorly with the public, they do look scared and on the run.

    By the time we're into an election campaign, Labour will not have turned down the election offer.

    Today's vote will be yesterday's fish and chip paper.
    I'm not so sure on that. Labour having to be dragged into an election will be brought up at every available opportunity.
    Meanwhile Labour will be shaking that mighty magic money tree within an inch of its life. It was very thoughtful for Javid to plant it for McDonnell today.
    I don't think going into another election promising more austerity would be a winner, but I also don't see how we can outbid Labour on spending.
    They can't but it will be enough to reassure working class Labour Leaver voters thinking of voting Tory over Corbyn's Brexit betrayal to make the final leap to Boris
    That strikes me as a poor strategy. But what do I know, I'm just a lowly analyst.
    It isn't it is the ONLY strategy that can get a Tory majority, most voters now oppose further austerity in the polls but also oppose further extension and want Brexit done
    Getting working class Labour voters to vote for the Tory party is a fools errand.
    WRONG, 6% of 2017 Labour voters are now voting Tory and only 1% of 2017 Tory voters are now voting Labour.

    8% of 2017 Labour voters are also now voting Brexit Party and just need one more push to come to Boris

    https://d25d2506sfb94s.cloudfront.net/cumulus_uploads/document/c68uv1jm1d/TheTimes_190903_VI_Trackers_w.pdf
    You just don’t understand. Visceral hatred of the tories is just a way of life up here. They may vote Brexit Party but not Tory.
    YOU just don't understand.

    6% SIX PERCENT of 2017 Labour voters are now voting Tory, just ONE percent of 2017 Tory voters are now voting Labour, that is more than enough for a Tory majority on its own and if the Labour Leave vote collapses to the Brexit Party that allows the Tories through the middle too in Labour Leave marginal seats
  • Options
    FF43 said:

    Floater said:

    TGOHF said:
    All day I have been getting whats app messages from friends and Corbyn is getting an absolute bollocking
    It only matters if those friends supported Corbyn in 2017.

    Having said that, Johnson's task isn't huge. He doesn't need a landslide. He just needs a net gain of 20 or more seats.
    Even if he just ends up with zero any net gains from the position in June 2017, he will still have replaced defectors and independents with new loyal Conservative MPs and will have a parliamentary party he can rely on in key votes. He would have won this week's votes if that he had that now. It would be a huge difference from the arithmetic he faced when he took over. He would also as a bonus have inflicted the same sort of existential damage on the BXP as Cameron inflicted on UKIP.

  • Options
    ChrisChris Posts: 11,121
    Noo said:

    tyson said:

    Let's go for that vote and have pics of Rees Mogg and Boris Johnson on every billboard.....

    Scope for making a series of Laurel & Hardy style images replete with "another fine mess" taglines.
    That said, I think it's usually a bad idea to put your opponent's faces on your literature.
    I think it depends who they are.
  • Options
    TOPPINGTOPPING Posts: 41,298
    .
    HYUFD said:

    TOPPING said:

    MaxPB said:

    MaxPB said:

    Hmm, it's going to be tough for Labour to use the unelected insult against Boris any more.

    I think them turning down an election will play very poorly with the public, they do look scared and on the run.

    After speaking to someone I know, they ventured their opinion on Brexit. They still don't understand why the 2016 vote did not mean we instantly left the EU! I tried explaining it is a bit more complicated than that but did not want to cause offence by outlining how things work or do not work. By the same token, the average person probably does not understand the FTPA and why Boris cannot have an election, so far. People think what they want to think and the sheer level of ignorance on democratic institutions and the processes involved seem to pass many citizens.
    Well all they will hear tonight and tomorrow (and the next few days) is that Boris wanted to have an election and Labour denied the people a say. As you rightly point out, the detail of whatever no deal blocking stuff will get lost in the small print. The headlines are "Labour vote down election". It's going to play very badly IMO.
    It all turns on October 31st. If we leave by then he is a hero. If we don't he is done for.
    Not necessarily, Boris has voted for No Deal and the WA at MV3 and to remove the backstop. the Commons has voted to stay in the EU past October 31st, against No Deal and against the WA.

    This week has been a PR exercise from Boris reassuring Leavers he is on their side against the diehard Remainer traitors in the Commons, he might try and ask the Queen to refuse royal assent but even if the Bill against No Deal passes led by Corbyn Boris can then call a general election backed by Labour with a mandate for Brexit having always voted to Leave on October 31st while Corbyn has always voted to Remain past October 31st and to leave the EU if the Tories win a majority straightaway.

    He can then watch the Labour Leave seats start to topple
    Yes. Except he is also against diehard remainer traitor voters such as yourself.

    Which is a problem either for you or Boris.
  • Options
    HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 116,991

    I can't think there is a lot happened the last 48 hrs that wasn't as expected. Maybe the numbers were a bit higher but I'm not sure about that - the lower numbers seemed to be wishful thinking.

    But Boris was a long way off how he performed just after taking office today, but not as bad as his detractors wish. The HofL stuff is where it is at at the moment - that seems to be just empty optimism to me.

    It is hard to disagree with Corbyn's logic on the GE vote.

    The Kinnock amendment is interesting and certainly a very minor win for Boris.

    Less obviously not getting the GE might be another minor win for Boris.

    Of course he has a measure of control of the house when the proprogation timetable sticks in - he only has to allow stuff he wants.

    Last time we had a GE on 15 Oct Labour won by 3.

    That was when Labour had won most seats in the last election and went from a hung parliament to a majority, the Tories won most seats in the previous election here
  • Options
    Scott_PScott_P Posts: 51,453

    The trouble with being an obsessive game theory player is if the other side don't give a fuck about game theory.

    Kick him in the OODA loop, see how he likes that...
  • Options
    GallowgateGallowgate Posts: 19,079
    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    MaxPB said:

    HYUFD said:

    MaxPB said:

    HYUFD said:

    MaxPB said:

    MaxPB said:

    MaxPB said:

    Hmm, it's going to be tough for Labour to use the unelected insult against Boris any more.

    I think them turning down an election will play very poorly with the public, they do look scared and on the run.

    By the time we're into an election campaign, Labour will not have turned down the election offer.

    Today's vote will be yesterday's fish and chip paper.
    I'm not so sure on that. Labour having to be dragged into an election will be brought up at every available opportunity.
    Meanwhile Labour will be shaking that mighty magic money tree within an inch of its life. It was very thoughtful for Javid to plant it for McDonnell today.
    I don't think going into another election promising more austerity would be a winner, but I also don't see how we can outbid Labour on spending.
    They can't but it will be enough to reassure working class Labour Leaver voters thinking of voting Tory over Corbyn's Brexit betrayal to make the final leap to Boris
    That strikes me as a poor strategy. But what do I know, I'm just a lowly analyst.
    It isn't it is the ONLY strategy that can get a Tory majority, most voters now oppose further austerity in the polls but also oppose further extension and want Brexit done
    Getting working class Labour voters to vote for the Tory party is a fools errand.
    WRONG, 6% of 2017 Labour voters are now voting Tory and only 1% of 2017 Tory voters are now voting Labour.

    8% of 2017 Labour voters are also now voting Brexit Party and just need one more push to come to Boris

    https://d25d2506sfb94s.cloudfront.net/cumulus_uploads/document/c68uv1jm1d/TheTimes_190903_VI_Trackers_w.pdf
    You just don’t understand. Visceral hatred of the tories is just a way of life up here. They may vote Brexit Party but not Tory.
    YOU just don't understand.

    6% SIX PERCENT of 2017 Labour voters are now voting Tory, just ONE percent of 2017 Tory voters are now voting Labour, that is more than enough for a Tory majority on its own and if the Labour Leave vote collapses to the Brexit Party that allows the Tories through the middle too in Labour Leave marginal seats
    If it makes you feel better.
  • Options
    GIN1138GIN1138 Posts: 20,815

    Scott_P said:
    He is Johnson's Steve Bannon.

    Gone before long.
    Just so long as he's around long enough to deliver a Con majority and Brexit afterwards he'll have done his job. :)
  • Options
    rcs1000 said:

    rcs1000 said:

    Ireland suggesting border checks could be done away from the border: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-49587610

    Gee who's been suggesting that?

    The backstop is b****ks and always has been.

    Are you being deliberately obtuse?

    We all know the correct technical solution to the border. There have been papers published, including by the European Commission, on the solution.

    The issue is not "is there a technical solution which removes the need for a hard border", it is "what happens between the end of the transition period and the implementation of the technical solution"?

    There is also the - very reasonable - fear that the EU or Ireland will drag their feet once we're in the backstop, and that's why binding international arbitration was added to the WA backstop text.
    I'm not being obtuse at all.

    If there is a correct technical solution to the border then lets drop the vile backstop, enter a transition [during which the backstop doesn't apply anyway], avoid the risk of no deal and work on the solution.

    I don't care if the EU or Ireland don't drag their feet once in the backstop. I object to being in the backstop full stop. And if there is an [imperfect] solution that can be done immediately in the event of no deal, it should be a reasonable fallback at the end of a transition.

    The answer to "what happens between the end of the transition period and the implementation of the technical solution" should not be the backstop IMO it should be "unless an agreement otherwise is reached at the time, then the same as would occur in a no deal scenario".
    The point is there is general agreement on the technical solution

    What there is not general agreement on is what happens between the end of the transition (due for end 2020) and its implementation.
    This is absolutely false. I have no idea why you persist in believing it.
  • Options
    CD13CD13 Posts: 6,351
    I can see a sustained burst of 'Let the people, not Parliament, decide.'

    A slogan based on Jezza's last two years of utterances.
  • Options
    BenpointerBenpointer Posts: 31,667
    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    MaxPB said:

    HYUFD said:

    MaxPB said:

    HYUFD said:

    MaxPB said:

    MaxPB said:

    MaxPB said:

    Hmm, it's going to be tough for Labour to use the unelected insult against Boris any more.

    I think them turning down an election will play very poorly with the public, they do look scared and on the run.

    By the time we're into an election campaign, Labour will not have turned down the election offer.

    Today's vote will be yesterday's fish and chip paper.
    I'm not so sure on that. Labour having to be dragged into an election will be brought up at every available opportunity.
    Meanwhile Labour will be shaking that mighty magic money tree within an inch of its life. It was very thoughtful for Javid to plant it for McDonnell today.
    I don't think going into another election promising more austerity would be a winner, but I also don't see how we can outbid Labour on spending.
    They can't but it will be enough to reassure working class Labour Leaver voters thinking of voting Tory over Corbyn's Brexit betrayal to make the final leap to Boris
    That strikes me as a poor strategy. But what do I know, I'm just a lowly analyst.
    It isn't it is the ONLY strategy that can get a Tory majority, most voters now oppose further austerity in the polls but also oppose further extension and want Brexit done
    Getting working class Labour voters to vote for the Tory party is a fools errand.
    WRONG, 6% of 2017 Labour voters are now voting Tory and only 1% of 2017 Tory voters are now voting Labour.

    8% of 2017 Labour voters are also now voting Brexit Party and just need one more push to come to Boris

    https://d25d2506sfb94s.cloudfront.net/cumulus_uploads/document/c68uv1jm1d/TheTimes_190903_VI_Trackers_w.pdf
    You just don’t understand. Visceral hatred of the tories is just a way of life up here. They may vote Brexit Party but not Tory.
    YOU just don't understand.

    6% SIX PERCENT of 2017 Labour voters are now voting Tory, just ONE percent of 2017 Tory voters are now voting Labour, that is more than enough for a Tory majority on its own and if the Labour Leave vote collapses to the Brexit Party that allows the Tories through the middle too in Labour Leave marginal seats
    None of them are VOTING at all - until we have a GE!
  • Options
    AlistairAlistair Posts: 23,670
    Byronic said:

    Scott_P said:
    I have no desire to be ungallant, but Caroline Spelman looks like quite an unconvincing mid 80s transsexual in an ill advised wig, in that photo
    I can't imagine why you wanted your posting history expunged.
  • Options
    Scott_P said:
    That's one of the great front pages for Bozo that HY referred to earlier.
  • Options
    GallowgateGallowgate Posts: 19,079
    The previous tweet was a typo apparently...

    https://twitter.com/bbclaurak/status/1169365639103991809?s=21
  • Options
    AlistairAlistair Posts: 23,670
    Imagine listing cathedrals and not mentioning Carlisle. Veey odd.
  • Options
    Scott_PScott_P Posts: 51,453
    Is Gove going to wield the knife again?

    https://twitter.com/tnewtondunn/status/1169361122295767041
  • Options
    HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 116,991
    Dominic Grieve says he may stand as an Independent at the next general election
  • Options
    PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 75,926
    26 minutes I make that from amendment 2C to 2D on the program motion
  • Options
    ByronicByronic Posts: 3,578
    tyson said:

    HYUFD said:

    TOPPING said:

    MaxPB said:

    MaxPB said:

    Hmm, it's going to be tough for Labour to use the unelected insult against Boris any more.

    I think them turning down an election will play very poorly with the public, they do look scared and on the run.

    After speaking to someone I know, they ventured their opinion on Brexit. They still don't understand why the 2016 vote did not mean we instantly left the EU! I tried explaining it is a bit more complicated than that but did not want to cause offence by outlining how things work or do not work. By the same token, the average person probably does not understand the FTPA and why Boris cannot have an election, so far. People think what they want to think and the sheer level of ignorance on democratic institutions and the processes involved seem to pass many citizens.
    Well all they will hear tonight and tomorrow (and the next few days) is that Boris wanted to have an election and Labour denied the people a say. As you rightly point out, the detail of whatever no deal blocking stuff will get lost in the small print. The headlines are "Labour vote down election". It's going to play very badly IMO.
    It all turns on October 31st. If we leave by then he is a hero. If we don't he is done for.
    Not necessarily, Boris has voted for No Deal and the WA at MV3 and to remove the backstop. the Commons has voted to stay in the EU past October 31st, against No Deal and against the WA.

    This week has been a PR exercise from Boris reassuring Leavers he is on their side against the diehard Remainer traitors in the Commons, he might try and ask the Queen to refuse royal assent but even if the Bill against No Deal passes led by Corbyn Boris can then call a general election backed by Labour with a mandate for Brexit having always voted to Leave on October 31st while Corbyn has always voted to Remain past October 31st and to leave the EU if the Tories win a majority straightaway.

    He can then watch the Labour Leave seats start to topple
    Haha....I don't think you quite realise just how repellant Boris Johnson is when we are faced with his entitled, narcissistic bluster day in and out....
    Let’s wait for the first proper polls. I predict all the Boris haters will be rather disappointed. But we shall see

    Night night from SPARTA
  • Options
    dr_spyndr_spyn Posts: 11,287
    edited September 2019
    Corbyn Clucks Up Brexit.

    May not be the most subtle headline, but more fowl word play from The Sun.
  • Options
    HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 116,991

    Scott_P said:
    That's one of the great front pages for Bozo that HY referred to earlier.
    From THE DAILY MIRROR, a paper so hard left it even backed Michael Foot over Margaret Thatcher in 1983
  • Options
    FoxyFoxy Posts: 44,601
    Alistair said:

    Imagine listing cathedrals and not mentioning Carlisle. Veey odd.

    Steeplehouses full of false idols...
  • Options
    MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 50,115
    Scott_P said:
    8 votes in 5 hours - only 192 more votes to come?
  • Options

    The previous tweet was a typo apparently...

    https://twitter.com/bbclaurak/status/1169365639103991809?s=21

    If true, 2019 looks unlikely. Once you get past 31 October, no one is going to thank you for a Christmas election. And no one seems to have noticed that with prorogation November is almost impossible to hit.
  • Options
    YBarddCwscYBarddCwsc Posts: 7,172
    edited September 2019

    Scott_P said:
    Penrith and Borders: Independent Conservative GAIN from Conservative.
    Not likely as a 55% leave seat. The only possibility if Lib/Lab stand down and give him a free run
    Which is entirely possible.
    Possible ... but not very easy.

    After all, have the LibDems even sorted out who is their candidate for Torbay?

    The party animal Dr Sarah Wollaston, or the loyal LibDem who has been nursing g the seat for 3 years, Caroline Voaden.
  • Options
    MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 50,115
  • Options
    PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 75,926

    Scott_P said:
    8 votes in 5 hours - only 192 more votes to come?
    Aren't there 86 on the program motion ?
  • Options
    TGOHFTGOHF Posts: 21,633

    The Sun front page is just comical.

    One for the ages - a masterpiece.
  • Options

    kle4 said:

    I think we can drop the 'unelected PM' bit. We all know how our PMs work, and that they don't require leading their party into an election, why imply there's something untoward about that?

    I think it is to do with the fact he cannot win a Parliamentary vote that is that makes it untoward.

    IIRC he is the PM with the fewest MPs since Ramsay MacDonald which did not turn out well for MacDonald.
    Luckily he has the legendary charm of the ultra-smooth Dominic Cummings to help him win over hearts and minds amongst MPs.
  • Options
    ChrisChris Posts: 11,121
    Scott_P said:
    Should they have put Boris Johnson's photo next to the word THIS?
  • Options
    MikeLMikeL Posts: 7,288
    If no GE until post 31 Oct, will Boris resign as PM around 17 Oct?
  • Options
    BenpointerBenpointer Posts: 31,667

    The previous tweet was a typo apparently...

    https://twitter.com/bbclaurak/status/1169365639103991809?s=21

    FFS Laura fecking-useless Kuenssberg!
  • Options
    GallowgateGallowgate Posts: 19,079
    What election?
  • Options
    FoxyFoxy Posts: 44,601
    Byronic said:

    tyson said:

    HYUFD said:

    TOPPING said:

    MaxPB said:

    MaxPB said:

    Hmm, it's going to be tough for Labour to use the unelected insult against Boris any more.

    I think them turning down an election will play very poorly with the public, they do look scared and on the run.

    After speaking to someone I know, they ventured their opinion on Brexit. They still don't understand why the 2016 vote did not mean we instantly left the EU! I tried explaining it is a bit more complicated than that but did not want to cause offence by outlining how things work or do not work. By the same token, the average person probably does not understand the FTPA and why Boris cannot have an election, so far. People think what they want to think and the sheer level of ignorance on democratic institutions and the processes involved seem to pass many citizens.
    Well all they will hear tonight and tomorrow (and the next few days) is that Boris wanted to have an election and Labour denied the people a say. As you rightly point out, the detail of whatever no deal blocking stuff will get lost in the small print. The headlines are "Labour vote down election". It's going to play very badly IMO.
    It all turns on October 31st. If we leave by then he is a hero. If we don't he is done for.
    Not necessarily, Boris has voted for No Deal and the WA at MV3 and to remove the backstop. the Commons has voted to stay in the EU past October 31st, against No Deal and against the WA.

    This week has been a PR exercise from Boris reassuring Leavers he is on their side against the diehard Remainer traitors in the Commons, he might try and ask the Queen to refuse royal assent but even if the Bill against No Deal passes led by Corbyn Boris can then call a general election backed by Labour with a mandate for Brexit having always voted to Leave on October 31st while Corbyn has always voted to Remain past October 31st and to leave the EU if the Tories win a majority straightaway.

    He can then watch the Labour Leave seats start to topple
    Haha....I don't think you quite realise just how repellant Boris Johnson is when we are faced with his entitled, narcissistic bluster day in and out....
    Let’s wait for the first proper polls. I predict all the Boris haters will be rather disappointed. But we shall see

    Night night from SPARTA
    Polls take a week or two to react. They are not as volatile as PB frothers.
  • Options
    So.. are Bozza/Cummings/Cleverley doubling-down despite the party uproar... or has this been mangled through the filter of some old duffer of a constituency chair who can't articulate the difference between the whip and party membership?


    https://twitter.com/KateEMcCann/status/1169359746308157445
  • Options
    DruttDrutt Posts: 1,093
    Credit to Saj for finding some spare change for rough sleepers today, but £50M between 5,000 street sleepers is ten grand per swagman. Are they all getting deposits for flats in Doncaster?

    https://mobile.twitter.com/ChristianGuy_/status/1169307262931939329
  • Options
    BenpointerBenpointer Posts: 31,667
    DM, Sun, Torygraph and Express slate Corbyn. Shocked I am.
  • Options
    surbiton19surbiton19 Posts: 1,469

    Scott_P said:
    8 votes in 5 hours - only 192 more votes to come?
    This is a zombie government. It wins a vote 298 to 56 in the HoC, and still loses !
  • Options
    HYUFD said:

    Scott_P said:
    That's one of the great front pages for Bozo that HY referred to earlier.
    From THE DAILY MIRROR, a paper so hard left it even backed Michael Foot over Margaret Thatcher in 1983
    You and the Mirror were on the same side in the Brexit Referendum.

    Marxist.
  • Options
    HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 116,991
    edited September 2019
    MikeL said:

    If no GE until post 31 Oct, will Boris resign as PM around 17 Oct?

    No, Boris would win a general election in November with a manifesto commitment to take us out of the EU as soon as he wins having voted to Leave on 31st October as he promised while Corbyn voted to extend
  • Options
    Danny565Danny565 Posts: 8,091
    edited September 2019

    The previous tweet was a typo apparently...

    https://twitter.com/bbclaurak/status/1169365639103991809?s=21

    If true, 2019 looks unlikely. Once you get past 31 October, no one is going to thank you for a Christmas election. And no one seems to have noticed that with prorogation November is almost impossible to hit.
    Also, the problem with November (or atleast, before the first few weeks of November) is that you would need the Commons to still be sitting on 31 October to ensure Boris keeps to his legal obligations, which presumably wouldn't be possible if the election campaign was in full swing at that point.

    That said, I wonder if there's something in that Tory peer's tweet from earlier about the government open to doing a deal with Labour to end the Lords filibuster on the No Deal Bill in exchange for Boris's election date...
  • Options
    GallowgateGallowgate Posts: 19,079
    HYUFD said:

    MikeL said:

    If no GE until post 31 Oct, will Boris resign as PM around 17 Oct?

    No, he will win a general election in November with a manifesto commitment to take us out of the EU as soon as he wins having voted to Leave on 31st October as he promised while Corbyn voted to extend
    But he said we’d be out no ifs no buts. 🤔
  • Options
    BenpointerBenpointer Posts: 31,667

    The previous tweet was a typo apparently...

    https://twitter.com/bbclaurak/status/1169365639103991809?s=21

    If true, 2019 looks unlikely. Once you get past 31 October, no one is going to thank you for a Christmas election. And no one seems to have noticed that with prorogation November is almost impossible to hit.
    Which does rather beg the question - will be be facing exactly the same situation in January?
  • Options
    Scott_P said:
    He would certainly be shortchanging himself by missing out on the payoff he will get when he loses.
  • Options
    Danny565 said:

    The previous tweet was a typo apparently...

    https://twitter.com/bbclaurak/status/1169365639103991809?s=21

    If true, 2019 looks unlikely. Once you get past 31 October, no one is going to thank you for a Christmas election. And no one seems to have noticed that with prorogation November is almost impossible to hit.
    Also, the problem with November (or atleast, before the first few weeks of November) is that you would need the Commons to still be sitting around 31 October, which presumably wouldn't be possible if the election campaign was in full swing at that point.

    That said, I wonder if there's something in that Tory peer's tweet from earlier about the government open to doing a deal with Labour to end the Lords filibuster on the No Deal Bill in exchange for Boris's election date...
    Of course the government is open to that. That would be Christmas for the Tories.
  • Options
    DruttDrutt Posts: 1,093
    Pulpstar said:

    Scott_P said:
    8 votes in 5 hours - only 192 more votes to come?
    Aren't there 86 on the program motion ?
    Part of the beauty of the lord's is that they effectively have a vote on whether to vote or not.
  • Options
    GIN1138GIN1138 Posts: 20,815
    Just saw Nick Watt reporting Boris will call off the fillibuster in HoL if Jezza agrees to an election.

    So Jezza can get NO DEAL off the table on 31st October by agreeing to a GE.

    But of course this isn't really about Brexit and No Deal at all is it? This is purely about Labour MPs being absolutely panic stricken at the prospect of having to face the electorate because they know the Lib-Dems will fillet them on the Remain side while Con/Brexit will fillet them on the Leave side.
  • Options
    BenpointerBenpointer Posts: 31,667

    HYUFD said:

    MikeL said:

    If no GE until post 31 Oct, will Boris resign as PM around 17 Oct?

    No, he will win a general election in November with a manifesto commitment to take us out of the EU as soon as he wins having voted to Leave on 31st October as he promised while Corbyn voted to extend
    But he said we’d be out no ifs no buts. 🤔
    +1

    "Under no circumstances will I ask for an extension."
  • Options
    surbiton19surbiton19 Posts: 1,469
    HYUFD said:

    Scott_P said:
    That's one of the great front pages for Bozo that HY referred to earlier.
    From THE DAILY MIRROR, a paper so hard left it even backed Michael Foot over Margaret Thatcher in 1983
    At least, not like one Lord Rothermere of the Daily Mail backed the Nazis.
  • Options
    HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 116,991
    edited September 2019
    Byronic said:

    tyson said:

    HYUFD said:

    TOPPING said:

    MaxPB said:

    MaxPB said:

    Hmm, it's going to be tough for Labour to use the unelected insult against Boris any more.

    I think them turning down an election will play very poorly with the public, they do look scared and on the run.

    After speaking to someone I know, they ventured their opinion on Brexit. They still don't understand why the 2016 vote did not mean we instantly left the EU! I tried explaining it is a bit more complicated than that but did not want to cause offence by outlining how things work or do not work. By the same token, the average person probably does not understand the FTPA and why Boris cannot have an election, so far. People think what they want to think and the sheer level of ignorance on democratic institutions and the processes involved seem to pass many citizens.
    Well all they will hear tonight and tomorrow (and the next few days) is that Boris wanted to have an election and Labour denied the people a say. As you rightly point out, the detail of whatever no deal blocking stuff will get lost in the small print. The headlines are "Labour vote down election". It's going to play very badly IMO.
    It all turns on October 31st. If we leave by then he is a hero. If we don't he is done for.
    Not necessarily, Boris has voted for No Deal and the WA at MV3 and to remove the backstop. the Commons has voted to stay in the EU past October 31st, against No Deal and against the WA.

    This week has been a PR exercise from Boris reassuring Leavers he is on their side against the diehard Remainer traitors in the Commons, he might try and ask the Queen to refuse royal assent but even if the Bill against No Deal passes led by Corbyn Boris can then call a general election backed by Labour with a mandate for Brexit having always voted to Leave on October 31st while Corbyn has always voted to Remain past October 31st and to leave the EU if the Tories win a majority straightaway.

    He can then watch the Labour Leave seats start to topple
    Haha....I don't think yo his entitled, narcissistic bluster day in and out....
    Let’s wait for the first proper polls. I predict all the Boris haters will be rather disappointed. But we shall see

    Night night from SPARTA
    Indeed, I have never, ever in my life wanted to win a general election as much as this one and I expect most real conservatives feel the same. In fact I could not care less if the Tories never win a general election for over a decade after as long as Boris wins this one, delivers Brexit, wipes the smug smile off the diehard Remainers and beats the treacherous Corbyn
  • Options

    The previous tweet was a typo apparently...

    https://twitter.com/bbclaurak/status/1169365639103991809?s=21

    If true, 2019 looks unlikely. Once you get past 31 October, no one is going to thank you for a Christmas election. And no one seems to have noticed that with prorogation November is almost impossible to hit.
    Which does rather beg the question - will be be facing exactly the same situation in January?
    And January 2021, and...
  • Options
    IanB2IanB2 Posts: 47,274
    Scott_P said:
    Hopefully he won’t be alone. Which might concentrate Tory minds a little.
  • Options
    HYUFD said:

    MikeL said:

    If no GE until post 31 Oct, will Boris resign as PM around 17 Oct?

    No, Boris would win a general election in November with a manifesto commitment to take us out of the EU as soon as he wins having voted to Leave on 31st October as he promised while Corbyn voted to extend
    Bozo will have resigned before a November GE if he is a man of his word. "Do or Die"
  • Options
    tysontyson Posts: 6,050
    Drutt said:

    Credit to Saj for finding some spare change for rough sleepers today, but £50M between 5,000 street sleepers is ten grand per swagman. Are they all getting deposits for flats in Doncaster?

    https://mobile.twitter.com/ChristianGuy_/status/1169307262931939329

    There are so many more than 5k rough sleepers in the UK......
  • Options
    TGOHFTGOHF Posts: 21,633

    HYUFD said:

    MikeL said:

    If no GE until post 31 Oct, will Boris resign as PM around 17 Oct?

    No, he will win a general election in November with a manifesto commitment to take us out of the EU as soon as he wins having voted to Leave on 31st October as he promised while Corbyn voted to extend
    But he said we’d be out no ifs no buts. 🤔
    We are still on course to leave on the 31st Oct.

  • Options
    GIN1138 said:

    HYUFD said:

    Great headlines for the Government tonight, Corbyn blocks Brexit and the Government ends austerity and increases spending on the NHS and police etc.

    What a constrast to GE17 when Corbyn promised to back Brexit and could attack May's Government over continued austerity

    It's hard to understand what's changed with Jezza since 2017? I always had him down a campaigner at heart. A politiican that was most at home away from the petty games of Westminster and out on the stump.

    It's very, very disappoitning.

    To think I've been toying with voting for him in recent months. :(
    Seriously? Didn't think a hardcore leaver such as yourself would consider voting for a party which would deliver you BRINO, even before Corbyn caved on offering a 2nd referendum.
  • Options
    BenpointerBenpointer Posts: 31,667
    Danny565 said:

    The previous tweet was a typo apparently...

    https://twitter.com/bbclaurak/status/1169365639103991809?s=21

    If true, 2019 looks unlikely. Once you get past 31 October, no one is going to thank you for a Christmas election. And no one seems to have noticed that with prorogation November is almost impossible to hit.
    Also, the problem with November (or atleast, before the first few weeks of November) is that you would need the Commons to still be sitting on 31 October to ensure Boris keeps to his legal obligations, which presumably wouldn't be possible if the election campaign was in full swing at that point.

    That said, I wonder if there's something in that Tory peer's tweet from earlier about the government open to doing a deal with Labour to end the Lords filibuster on the No Deal Bill in exchange for Boris's election date...
    It doesn't look as if the HoL filibuster is going to work anyway. Government numbers dropping as it gets past bedtime.
  • Options
    The_TaxmanThe_Taxman Posts: 2,979
    Scott_P said:
    Which probably means that CCHQ will have to divert resources from other seats, which, the Tories could have used to target Labour seats or defence against LD/SNP. A campaign has finite resources and you can only spend a pound once or have an individual in one place at a time. Independents turning safe seats into marginals is a really clever move by Boris and co! I wonder if they wargamed that as well?
  • Options
    Danny565 said:

    The previous tweet was a typo apparently...

    https://twitter.com/bbclaurak/status/1169365639103991809?s=21

    If true, 2019 looks unlikely. Once you get past 31 October, no one is going to thank you for a Christmas election. And no one seems to have noticed that with prorogation November is almost impossible to hit.
    Also, the problem with November (or atleast, before the first few weeks of November) is that you would need the Commons to still be sitting around 31 October, which presumably wouldn't be possible if the election campaign was in full swing at that point.

    That said, I wonder if there's something in that Tory peer's tweet from earlier about the government open to doing a deal with Labour to end the Lords filibuster on the No Deal Bill in exchange for Boris's election date...
    It won't fly. There would be nothing to stop Labour reneging on the promise once the filibuster had ended.
  • Options
    Danny565Danny565 Posts: 8,091
    Chris said:

    Scott_P said:
    Should they have put Boris Johnson's photo next to the word THIS?
    No doubt Radio 4 tomorrow morning will carry an interview with Amber saying how jolly cross she is about it at all, before doing precisely nothing to change things.
  • Options
    AndyJSAndyJS Posts: 29,395
    William Waldegrave being very defeatist about the UK on Newsnight.
  • Options
    surbiton19surbiton19 Posts: 1,469

    Scott_P said:
    He would certainly be shortchanging himself by missing out on the payoff he will get when he loses.
    Irrespective, he will still be paid.
  • Options
    AndyJSAndyJS Posts: 29,395
    GIN1138 said:

    Just saw Nick Watt reporting Boris will call off the fillibuster in HoL if Jezza agrees to an election.

    So Jezza can get NO DEAL off the table on 31st October by agreeing to a GE.

    But of course this isn't really about Brexit and No Deal at all is it? This is purely about Labour MPs being absolutely panic stricken at the prospect of having to face the electorate because they know the Lib-Dems will fillet them on the Remain side while Con/Brexit will fillet them on the Leave side.

    +1
  • Options
    AnabobazinaAnabobazina Posts: 19,981

    The previous tweet was a typo apparently...

    https://twitter.com/bbclaurak/status/1169365639103991809?s=21

    Lol. Laura K really is well worth missing.
  • Options
    If the s*n don’t have an intern dressed as a chicken following Mr. Corbyn around tomorrow I shall be surprised
  • Options
    FoxyFoxy Posts: 44,601

    Scott_P said:
    Which probably means that CCHQ will have to divert resources from other seats, which, the Tories could have used to target Labour seats or defence against LD/SNP. A campaign has finite resources and you can only spend a pound once or have an individual in one place at a time. Independents turning safe seats into marginals is a really clever move by Boris and co! I wonder if they wargamed that as well?
    Particularly if they run as Independent Remainer, with the Remain parties standing down...
  • Options
    TOPPINGTOPPING Posts: 41,298
    HYUFD said:

    Byronic said:

    tyson said:

    HYUFD said:

    TOPPING said:

    MaxPB said:

    MaxPB said:

    Hmm, it's going to be tough for Labour to use the unelected insult against Boris any more.

    I think them turning down an election will play very poorly with the public, they do look scared and on the run.

    After speaking to someone I know, they ventured their opinion on Brexit. They still don't understand why the 2016 vote did not mean we instantly left the EU! I tried explaining it is a bit more complicated than that but did not want to causso far. People think what they want to think and the sheer level of ignorance on democratic institutions and the processes involved seem to pass many citizens.
    Well all they will hear tonight and tomorrow (and the next few days) is that Boris wanted to have an election and Labour denied the people a say. As you rightly point out, the detail of whatever no deal blocking stuff will get lost in the small print. The headlines are "Labour vote down election". It's going to play very badly IMO.
    It all turns on October 31st. If we leave by then he is a hero. If we don't he is done for.
    Not necessarily, Boris has voted for No Deal and the WA at MV3 and to remove the backstop. the Commons has voted to stay in the EU past October 31st, against No Deal and against the WA.

    This week has been a PR exercise from Boris reassuring Leavers he is on their side against the diehard Remainer traitors in the Commons, he might try and ask the Queen to refuse royal assent but even if the Bill against No Deal passes led by Corbyn Boris can then call a general election backed by Labour with a mandate for Brexit having always voted to Leave on October 31st while Corbyn has always voted to Remain past October 31st and to leave the EU if the Tories win a majority straightaway.

    He can then watch the Labour Leave seats start to topple
    Haha....I don't think yo his entitled, narcissistic bluster day in and out....
    Let’s wait for the first proper polls. I predict all the Boris haters will be rather disappointed. But we shall see

    Night night from SPARTA
    Indeed, I have never, ever in my life wanted to win a general election as much as this one and I expect most real conservatives feel the same. In fact I could not care less if the Tories never win a general election for over a decade after as long as Boris wins this one, delivers Brexit, wipes the smug smile off the diehard Remainers and beats the treacherous Corbyn
    Why would you want to wipe the smug smile off your own face?
  • Options
    If Johnson won a majority before the EU summit, the only possible alternative deal he could do would be to go back to the EU's original draft with the NI-only backstop. Perhaps HYUFD was half right.
  • Options

    The previous tweet was a typo apparently...

    https://twitter.com/bbclaurak/status/1169365639103991809?s=21

    If true, 2019 looks unlikely. Once you get past 31 October, no one is going to thank you for a Christmas election. And no one seems to have noticed that with prorogation November is almost impossible to hit.
    Which does rather beg the question - will be be facing exactly the same situation in January?
    And January 2021, and...

    Johnson’s entire strategy has been based on getting an election before 31st October. What’s he going to do if he doesn’t get one?

  • Options
    YBarddCwscYBarddCwsc Posts: 7,172
    TOPPING said:



    Why would you want to wipe the smug smile off your own face?

    I find your endless sniping at HYUFD close to bullying.

    I don't happen to agree with HYUFD, but he is at least amiable.
  • Options
    The_TaxmanThe_Taxman Posts: 2,979
    Foxy said:

    Scott_P said:
    Which probably means that CCHQ will have to divert resources from other seats, which, the Tories could have used to target Labour seats or defence against LD/SNP. A campaign has finite resources and you can only spend a pound once or have an individual in one place at a time. Independents turning safe seats into marginals is a really clever move by Boris and co! I wonder if they wargamed that as well?
    Particularly if they run as Independent Remainer, with the Remain parties standing down...
    Indeed, like Martin Bell in two dozen seats! :wink:
  • Options
    TabmanTabman Posts: 1,046

    HYUFD said:

    MikeL said:

    If no GE until post 31 Oct, will Boris resign as PM around 17 Oct?

    No, Boris would win a general election in November with a manifesto commitment to take us out of the EU as soon as he wins having voted to Leave on 31st October as he promised while Corbyn voted to extend
    Bozo will have resigned before a November GE if he is a man of his word. "Do or Die"
    Man of his word ROFLMAO
  • Options

    HYUFD said:

    MikeL said:

    If no GE until post 31 Oct, will Boris resign as PM around 17 Oct?

    No, he will win a general election in November with a manifesto commitment to take us out of the EU as soon as he wins having voted to Leave on 31st October as he promised while Corbyn voted to extend
    But he said we’d be out no ifs no buts. 🤔
    But Parliament has prevented it and is too chicken to have an election so he'll need a majority. Problem solved.

    If you think Boris calling the obstructionist MPs cowards denying the democratic will for 2 months will end with Boris being unpopular you have odd logic.
  • Options
    AnabobazinaAnabobazina Posts: 19,981

    Scott_P said:
    Which probably means that CCHQ will have to divert resources from other seats, which, the Tories could have used to target Labour seats or defence against LD/SNP. A campaign has finite resources and you can only spend a pound once or have an individual in one place at a time. Independents turning safe seats into marginals is a really clever move by Boris and co! I wonder if they wargamed that as well?
    I think the likes of Grieve and the two Hammonds would stand decent chances. I recall all are in Remain seats - presumably the official Tory candidates will be hardcore Leaver europhobes, to comply with Boris’ purge parameters?
  • Options
    GIN1138GIN1138 Posts: 20,815

    GIN1138 said:

    HYUFD said:

    Great headlines for the Government tonight, Corbyn blocks Brexit and the Government ends austerity and increases spending on the NHS and police etc.

    What a constrast to GE17 when Corbyn promised to back Brexit and could attack May's Government over continued austerity

    It's hard to understand what's changed with Jezza since 2017? I always had him down a campaigner at heart. A politiican that was most at home away from the petty games of Westminster and out on the stump.

    It's very, very disappoitning.

    To think I've been toying with voting for him in recent months. :(
    Seriously? Didn't think a hardcore leaver such as yourself would consider voting for a party which would deliver you BRINO, even before Corbyn caved on offering a 2nd referendum.
    Well at one point I couldn't see how any Brexit would happen any other way except Jezza implementing it.

    And remember I'd have voted for May's deal on MV2 and MV3 and though the ERG etc were dumb not to...
  • Options
    PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 75,926
    Motion 2E slightly quicker, only 21 minutes from the last "clear the bar" to this one.
  • Options
    HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 116,991

    Scott_P said:
    Which probably means that CCHQ will have to divert resources from other seats, which, the Tories could have used to target Labour seats or defence against LD/SNP. A campaign has finite resources and you can only spend a pound once or have an individual in one place at a time. Independents turning safe seats into marginals is a really clever move by Boris and co! I wonder if they wargamed that as well?
    They won't, the Tories got 65% in Beaconsfield in 2017, even if that vote split 50-50 between the Tory candidate and Grieve given Labour only got 21% and the LDs got 7% one of them would still win
  • Options
    NigelbNigelb Posts: 62,583
    HYUFD said:

    Byronic said:

    tyson said:

    HYUFD said:

    TOPPING said:

    MaxPB said:



    After speaking to someone I know, they ventured their opinion on Brexit. They still don't understand why the 2016 vote did not mean we instantly left the EU! I tried explain....does not understand the FTPA and why Boris cannot have an election, so far. People think what they want to think and the sheer level of ignorance on democratic institutions and the processes involved seem to pass many citizens.

    Well all they will hear tonight and tomorrow (and the next few days) is that Boris wanted to have an election and Labour denied the people a say. As you rightly point out, the detail of whatever no deal blocking stuff will get lost in the small print. The headlines are "Labour vote down election". It's going to play very badly IMO.
    It all turns on October 31st. If we leave by then he is a hero. If we don't he is done for.
    Not necessarily, Boris has voted for No Deal and the WA at MV3 and to remove the backstop. the Commons has voted to stay in the EU past October 31st, against No Deal and against the WA.

    This week has been a PR exercise from Boris reassuring Leavers he is on their side against the diehard Remainer traitors in the Commons, he might try and ask the Queen to refuse royal assent but even if the Bill against No Deal passes led by Corbyn Boris can then call a general election backed by Labour with a mandate for Brexit having always voted to Leave on October 31st while Corbyn has always voted to Remain past October 31st and to leave the EU if the Tories win a majority straightaway.

    He can then watch the Labour Leave seats start to topple
    Haha....I don't think yo his entitled, narcissistic bluster day in and out....
    Let’s wait for the first proper polls. I predict all the Boris haters will be rather disappointed. But we shall see

    Night night from SPARTA
    Indeed, I have never, ever in my life wanted to win a general election as much as this one and I expect most real conservatives feel the same. In fact I could not care less if the Tories never win a general election for over a decade after as long as Boris wins this one, delivers Brexit, wipes the smug smile off the diehard Remainers and beats the treacherous Corbyn
    Given the comment, it seems appropriate to ask, how old are you ?
  • Options
    HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 116,991

    HYUFD said:

    MikeL said:

    If no GE until post 31 Oct, will Boris resign as PM around 17 Oct?

    No, he will win a general election in November with a manifesto commitment to take us out of the EU as soon as he wins having voted to Leave on 31st October as he promised while Corbyn voted to extend
    But he said we’d be out no ifs no buts. 🤔
    We will not be out thanks to Jeremy Corbyn who voted to extend while Boris voted to Leave on 31st October
  • Options
    NooNoo Posts: 2,380

    TOPPING said:



    Why would you want to wipe the smug smile off your own face?

    I find your endless sniping at HYUFD close to bullying.

    I don't happen to agree with HYUFD, but he is at least amiable.
    Amiable people don't go around calling people traitors just for having policies they dislike.
  • Options
    surbiton19surbiton19 Posts: 1,469
    Nigelb said:

    HYUFD said:

    Byronic said:

    tyson said:

    HYUFD said:

    TOPPING said:

    MaxPB said:



    After speaking to someone I know, they ventured their opinion on Brexit. They still don't understand why the 2016 vote did not mean we instantly left the EU! I tried explain....does not understand the FTPA and why Boris cannot have an election, so far. People think what they want to think and the sheer level of ignorance on democratic institutions and the processes involved seem to pass many citizens.

    Well all they will hear tonight and tomorrow (and the next few days) is that Boris wanted to have an election and Labour denied the people a say. As you rightly point out, the detail of whatever no deal blocking stuff will get lost in the small print. The headlines are "Labour vote down election". It's going to play very badly IMO.
    It all turns on October 31st. If we leave by then he is a hero. If we don't he is done for.
    Not necessarily, Boris has voted for No Deal and the WA at MV3 and to remove the backstop. the Commons has voted to stay in the EU past October 31st, against No Deal and against the WA.

    This week has been a PR exercise from Boris reassuring Leavers he is on their side against the diehard Remainer traitors in the Commons, he might try and ask the Queen to refuse royal assent but even if the Bill against No Deal passes led by Corbyn Boris can then call a general election backed by Labour with a mandate for Brexit having always voted to Leave on October 31st while Corbyn has always voted to Remain past October 31st and to leave the EU if the Tories win a majority straightaway.

    He can then watch the Labour Leave seats start to topple
    Haha....I don't think yo his entitled, narcissistic bluster day in and out....
    Let’s wait for the first proper polls. I predict all the Boris haters will be rather disappointed. But we shall see

    Night night from SPARTA
    Indeed, I have never, ever in my life wanted to win a general election as much as this one and I expect most real conservatives feel the same. In fact I could not care less if the Tories never win a general election for over a decade after as long as Boris wins this one, delivers Brexit, wipes the smug smile off the diehard Remainers and beats the treacherous Corbyn
    Given the comment, it seems appropriate to ask, how old are you ?
    4 years old.
  • Options
    HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 116,991

    TOPPING said:



    Why would you want to wipe the smug smile off your own face?

    I find your endless sniping at HYUFD close to bullying.

    I don't happen to agree with HYUFD, but he is at least amiable.
    Thankyou though it is more just annoying than bullying
This discussion has been closed.