Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

Options

politicalbetting.com » Blog Archive » 2019 now moves to the favourite slot as year of the next gener

SystemSystem Posts: 11,020
edited June 2019 in General

imagepoliticalbetting.com » Blog Archive » 2019 now moves to the favourite slot as year of the next general election

Chart of Betfair price movements from Betdata.io

Read the full story here


«134567

Comments

  • Options
    chloechloe Posts: 308
    First?
  • Options
    dixiedeandixiedean Posts: 27,965
    First like Bozza! Tally Ho!
  • Options
    OldKingColeOldKingCole Posts: 31,983
    First, having returned from watching the women cricket, which at the time I left was almost certain to be rained off,
  • Options
    Morris_DancerMorris_Dancer Posts: 60,983
    O tempora! O mores!
  • Options
    chloechloe Posts: 308
    Can’t see how Boris is going to be any more successful than May in resolving Brexit.
  • Options
    Philip_ThompsonPhilip_Thompson Posts: 65,826
    Boris should challenge Barnier to a game of wiff-waff to sort out Brexit.
  • Options
    dixiedeandixiedean Posts: 27,965
    dixiedean said:

    First like Bozza! Tally Ho!

    Obviously not...lay the favourite?
  • Options
    ThomasNasheThomasNashe Posts: 4,971
    Do we know if he'll be taking part in the Channel 4 debate on Sunday? Because not turning up for the TV debate worked out really well for TMay in 2017 ...
  • Options
    dixiedeandixiedean Posts: 27,965
    chloe said:

    Can’t see how Boris is going to be any more successful than May in resolving Brexit.

    I fear that is not the point. The point is keeping the Tory Party in the first 2 after the next GE.
  • Options
    ThomasNasheThomasNashe Posts: 4,971
    chloe said:

    Can’t see how Boris is going to be any more successful than May in resolving Brexit.

    The opposition from both the EU and Parliament will be much more entrenched.
  • Options
    DavidLDavidL Posts: 51,280
    FPT
    O/T but another "interesting" decision from the Supreme Court: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-birmingham-48625914?intlink_from_url=https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business&link_location=live-reporting-story

    A woman who prioritised buying food for her children over her rent was not "intentionally homeless". It was "reasonable" for her to do so.

    To me this is the sort of decision that Lord Sumption has been having a go at in his Reith lectures. This isn't law, its politics. And our judges are not best placed to make political decisions.
  • Options
    FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 76,285
    Haaaazzzzzzzahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh....late to the new thread like Boris practising the pull out technique.
  • Options
    williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 48,058
    Tory recovery plan:

    - Snap election in September.
    - Big majority for Boris.
    - Second referendum in 2020.
  • Options
    Philip_ThompsonPhilip_Thompson Posts: 65,826
    chloe said:

    Can’t see how Boris is going to be any more successful than May in resolving Brexit.

    Can't be any worse.
  • Options
    MikeLMikeL Posts: 7,288
    Other change today is towards Con winning the next GE.

    Most seats:
    Con 2.08
    Lab 2.52

    Overall Majority:
    Con 3.65
    Lab 7
  • Options
    FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 76,285

    Tory recovery plan:

    - Snap election in September.
    - Big majority for Boris.
    - Second referendum in 2020.

    Why would they bother with #3?
  • Options
    EndillionEndillion Posts: 4,976

    Tory recovery plan:

    - Snap election in September.
    - Big majority for Boris.
    - Second referendum in 2020.

    Why on earth does he call for a second referendum if he's just won a mandate for his preferred form of Brexit?
  • Options
    williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 48,058

    Tory recovery plan:

    - Snap election in September.
    - Big majority for Boris.
    - Second referendum in 2020.

    Why would they bother with #3?
    To get off the hook for delivering Brexit.
  • Options
    Philip_ThompsonPhilip_Thompson Posts: 65,826

    Tory recovery plan:

    - Snap election in September.
    - Big majority for Boris.
    - Second referendum in 2020.

    Why would they bother with #3?
    This is williamglenn, he's a broken record.

    We could actually no deal exit on 31 October and he would on 1 November still be talking up a second referendum.
  • Options
    FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 76,285

    Tory recovery plan:

    - Snap election in September.
    - Big majority for Boris.
    - Second referendum in 2020.

    Why would they bother with #3?
    To get off the hook for delivering Brexit.
    Your dreaming if you think that will happen. If Boris wins a massive majority on the basis on getting Brexit through, they aren't going to go for a second referendum.
  • Options
    nico67nico67 Posts: 4,502
    The veneer continues to peel away from the so called Brexit for sovereignty mantra .

    I wonder what the response would be if a different PM suspended parliament so that they could send the Article 50 revocation letter .

    The fact so many Leavers are happy to turn the UK into a dictatorship as long as they can get their deluded no deal shows once again what they really think of sovereignty .



  • Options
    williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 48,058

    Tory recovery plan:

    - Snap election in September.
    - Big majority for Boris.
    - Second referendum in 2020.

    Why would they bother with #3?
    To get off the hook for delivering Brexit.
    Your dreaming if you think that will happen. If Boris wins a massive majority on the basis on getting Brexit through, they aren't going to go for a second referendum.
    The most accurate way to predict the future is to start from the assumption that Brexit won't happen, and then work backwards from there to fit the current circumstances. ;)
  • Options
    IanB2IanB2 Posts: 47,274

    Tory recovery plan:

    - Snap election in September.
    - Big majority for Boris.
    - Second referendum in 2020.

    Why would they bother with #3?
    To get off the hook for delivering Brexit.
    Your dreaming if you think that will happen. If Boris wins a massive majority on the basis on getting Brexit through, they aren't going to go for a second referendum.
    Massive surely isn't within the bounds of reasonable outcomes
  • Options
    Nigel_ForemainNigel_Foremain Posts: 13,781

    Tory recovery plan:

    - Snap election in September.
    - Big majority for Boris.
    - Second referendum in 2020.

    Why would they bother with #3?
    This is williamglenn, he's a broken record.

    We could actually no deal exit on 31 October and he would on 1 November still be talking up a second referendum.
    At least he isn't talking up war with our European allies.
  • Options
    TGOHFTGOHF Posts: 21,633
    Boris about the same odds as the Brexit party at 9pm on the day of the bye election.
  • Options
    rural_voterrural_voter Posts: 2,038
    FPT
    kinabalu said:

    I think you are right - Labour would offer a Referendum in a pre-Brexit GE. Corbyn is no lover of the EU but the threat of a LD/Green mop-up of the Remainer vote is too much for him to risk. I think he cares about having the power to implement his domestic policies, more than he cares about Brexit.

    Yes. Him and McDonnell. Lifelong socialist outsiders. Now, unexpectedly, with a chance to be PM and Chancellor. Pushing 70, the both of them, and surely aware that this is their one and only shot. Will do what it takes. Will do what maximizes their chance of winning. Might not be enough, but they will not be leaving anything on the bench and that includes the referendum commitment. It will be starting.
    McDonnell is pro-EU membership now I think and so are lots of lefties who may have been against it 40 years ago:

    Lansman
    Livingstone
    Abbott
    Lewis

    Even being a socialist and a Euro-federalist is good for you. Delors is still going, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jacques_Delors
  • Options
    rottenboroughrottenborough Posts: 58,216
    In a wild moment I have topped up further on Rory.

    As everything in politics has become so unpredictable and weird, why not him coming out of nowhere and emerging as the Stop Boris candidate who goes to the membership, just as Boris implodes?
  • Options
    TGOHFTGOHF Posts: 21,633

    Tory recovery plan:

    - Snap election in September.
    - Big majority for Boris.
    - Second referendum in 2020.

    Lol - if they get 2 why would they go near 3 ?

  • Options
    TGOHFTGOHF Posts: 21,633
    chloe said:

    Can’t see how Boris is going to be any more successful than May in resolving Brexit.

    May is a terrible politician.

    Boris's team just needs to be average.
  • Options
    TGOHFTGOHF Posts: 21,633

    Tory recovery plan:

    - Snap election in September.
    - Big majority for Boris.
    - Second referendum in 2020.

    Why would they bother with #3?
    This is williamglenn, he's a broken record.

    We could actually no deal exit on 31 October and he would on 1 November still be talking up a second referendum.
    In 2022 he will be telling us just because Jezza doesn't have rejoin in the Labour manifesto, that doesn't mean its not nailed on.
  • Options
    kinabalukinabalu Posts: 39,187
    TGOHF said:

    Boris about the same odds as the Brexit party at 9pm on the day of the bye election.

    Nice one.
    :smile:
  • Options
    GIN1138GIN1138 Posts: 20,815
    edited June 2019

    Tory recovery plan:

    - Snap election in September.
    - Big majority for Boris.
    - Second referendum in 2020.

    Why would they bother with #3?
    Cause in William's world all roads lead to REMAIN :D
  • Options

    Tory recovery plan:

    - Snap election in September.
    - Big majority for Boris.
    - Second referendum in 2020.

    And then you woke up.

    As has been said before, the survival of the Tory Party now depends on Brexit happening. It would be like a Labour government being elected and abolishing the NHS, or a Ukip government joining the EU. It is in the DNA.
  • Options
    Philip_ThompsonPhilip_Thompson Posts: 65,826

    Tory recovery plan:

    - Snap election in September.
    - Big majority for Boris.
    - Second referendum in 2020.

    Why would they bother with #3?
    This is williamglenn, he's a broken record.

    We could actually no deal exit on 31 October and he would on 1 November still be talking up a second referendum.
    At least he isn't talking up war with our European allies.
    Neither was I. I was saying that what eek ludicrously proposed was the EU declaring war, to which we would have to respond - which then got you muppets piling in on me like I was saying we should launch a pre-emptive nuclear strike.
  • Options
    chloechloe Posts: 308
    TGOHF said:

    chloe said:

    Can’t see how Boris is going to be any more successful than May in resolving Brexit.

    May is a terrible politician.

    Boris's team just needs to be average.
    I hope he is better at being PM than he was Foreign Secretary.
  • Options
    rottenboroughrottenborough Posts: 58,216

    Tory recovery plan:

    - Snap election in September.
    - Big majority for Boris.
    - Second referendum in 2020.

    And then you woke up.

    As has been said before, the survival of the Tory Party now depends on Brexit happening. It would be like a Labour government being elected and abolishing the NHS, or a Ukip government joining the EU. It is in the DNA.
    Wouldn't Boris need to recall HoC to have a snap election in September?
  • Options
    rottenboroughrottenborough Posts: 58,216
  • Options
    kle4kle4 Posts: 91,744
    Why was it not already the favourite year? The plan a of all candidates wont work and it's the easiest plan b for them to go for a GE.
  • Options
    williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 48,058
  • Options
    Nigel_ForemainNigel_Foremain Posts: 13,781

    Tory recovery plan:

    - Snap election in September.
    - Big majority for Boris.
    - Second referendum in 2020.

    Why would they bother with #3?
    This is williamglenn, he's a broken record.

    We could actually no deal exit on 31 October and he would on 1 November still be talking up a second referendum.
    At least he isn't talking up war with our European allies.
    Neither was I. I was saying that what eek ludicrously proposed was the EU declaring war, to which we would have to respond - which then got you muppets piling in on me like I was saying we should launch a pre-emptive nuclear strike.
    You talked of casus belli. It was the most ridiculous piece of jingoism I have seen in the whole of the Brexit debate, and that is saying something. We were not the muppets, you made a complete idiot of yourself and the cause that you seek to speak up for. You have made yourself a parody of a leaver, if that is even possible.
  • Options
    DavidLDavidL Posts: 51,280

    In a wild moment I have topped up further on Rory.

    As everything in politics has become so unpredictable and weird, why not him coming out of nowhere and emerging as the Stop Boris candidate who goes to the membership, just as Boris implodes?

    I wish you luck.
  • Options
    TheWhiteRabbitTheWhiteRabbit Posts: 12,388
    Continuity TIG?
  • Options
    PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 75,926

    In a wild moment I have topped up further on Rory.

    As everything in politics has become so unpredictable and weird, why not him coming out of nowhere and emerging as the Stop Boris candidate who goes to the membership, just as Boris implodes?

    Save your money, back Warren for POTUS if you need to go for something at around that price
  • Options
    rottenboroughrottenborough Posts: 58,216
    Pulpstar said:

    In a wild moment I have topped up further on Rory.

    As everything in politics has become so unpredictable and weird, why not him coming out of nowhere and emerging as the Stop Boris candidate who goes to the membership, just as Boris implodes?

    Save your money, back Warren for POTUS if you need to go for something at around that price
    Thanks. I will have a look.
  • Options
    algarkirkalgarkirk Posts: 10,534

    Tory recovery plan:

    - Snap election in September.
    - Big majority for Boris.
    - Second referendum in 2020.

    Why would they bother with #3?
    To get off the hook for delivering Brexit.
    Your dreaming if you think that will happen. If Boris wins a massive majority on the basis on getting Brexit through, they aren't going to go for a second referendum.
    The most accurate way to predict the future is to start from the assumption that Brexit won't happen, and then work backwards from there to fit the current circumstances. ;)
    Quite reasonable. There is only about one way of leaving the EU in a realistic way and that is to join EFTA, or act equivalently, until a longer term plan emerges. This has been prevented so far, though with TMs deal it would not have been quite impossible. Remaining, or EFTA aka 'Norway for Now' is something Boris could have the courage, unscrupulousness, cheek and leadership to deliver. Very doubtful if anyone else could.

    EFTA is a perfectly reasonable result of a 52/48 referendum. it's not as if Norway and Switzerland are basket cases. A second referendum could provide cover for either that or remain. Personally I prefer EFTA for all the reasons Richard North has exhaustively, and exhaustingly, given. BTW it would be hard to say who hates Boris most as there are so many candidates but Dr North must be in the frame for that position.

  • Options
    OldKingColeOldKingCole Posts: 31,983

    Continuity TIG?
    How not to start a political party.
  • Options
    MikeLMikeL Posts: 7,288
    Rules Question:

    What happens if Boris is the only person to get 33 votes in Round 2? Would he be declared winner or would top 2 still go to members?

    It's not actually that far off from happening - would only need Hunt and Gove to lose a few votes.

    If threshold in Round 2 had been 15% and not 10% then it easily could have happened!
  • Options
    TOPPINGTOPPING Posts: 41,298

    Tory recovery plan:

    - Snap election in September.
    - Big majority for Boris.
    - Second referendum in 2020.

    And then you woke up.

    As has been said before, the survival of the Tory Party now depends on Brexit happening. It would be like a Labour government being elected and abolishing the NHS, or a Ukip government joining the EU. It is in the DNA.

    Tory recovery plan:

    - Snap election in September.
    - Big majority for Boris.
    - Second referendum in 2020.

    And then you woke up.

    As has been said before, the survival of the Tory Party now depends on Brexit happening. It would be like a Labour government being elected and abolishing the NHS, or a Ukip government joining the EU. It is in the DNA.
    Very true. While of course no dealing will destroy them as an electoral force for time to come. Great croquet parties though to look forward to.
  • Options
    FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 76,285
    edited June 2019

    Tory recovery plan:

    - Snap election in September.
    - Big majority for Boris.
    - Second referendum in 2020.

    Why would they bother with #3?
    To get off the hook for delivering Brexit.
    Your dreaming if you think that will happen. If Boris wins a massive majority on the basis on getting Brexit through, they aren't going to go for a second referendum.
    The most accurate way to predict the future is to start from the assumption that Brexit won't happen, and then work backwards from there to fit the current circumstances. ;)
    Boris winning a big majority ain't going to happen. The Tories under Boris absolute best case is scraping a majority with the combination of those who want Brexit and the never Corbyn's, with just the correct amount of Labour voters splitting to Lib Dems because of Jezza's fence sitting.
  • Options
    RobDRobD Posts: 58,967
    I wonder who May voted for.
  • Options
    CyclefreeCyclefree Posts: 25,205
    chloe said:

    TGOHF said:

    chloe said:

    Can’t see how Boris is going to be any more successful than May in resolving Brexit.

    May is a terrible politician.

    Boris's team just needs to be average.
    I hope he is better at being PM than he was Foreign Secretary.
    I think we can safely assume he won’t be.

    He is untrustworthy, a liar, afraid of scrutiny, a bit of a bully (expecting photos of the votes for him has a hint of G. Brown-style menace ), incompetent, frivolous and is not respected. He simply is not serious or thoughtful.

    His election as leader will neutralise many of the attacks that could be made against Corbyn and his move towards Brexit and even the contemplation of shutting down Parliament will alienate many of those who voted for him in the past.

    If the Tories choose him it simply shows that they are no longer a serious party, that old-fashioned, sensible Conservatism is dead and that they put the interests of their own party above those of the country.

    The Tories are not thinking straight. Choosing Boris is simply them indulging in a group hug. (A much more vulgar term would be more accurate but it is still early and this is a respectable site.)

  • Options
    rottenboroughrottenborough Posts: 58,216
    RobD said:

    I wonder who May voted for.

    Odd that there were no spoilt ballot papers.

    I expected her to write her name in and then 'nothing has changed'.
  • Options
    RobD said:

    I wonder who May voted for.

    Hunt.
  • Options
    rpjsrpjs Posts: 3,787
    edited June 2019
    TOPPING said:

    Tory recovery plan:

    - Snap election in September.
    - Big majority for Boris.
    - Second referendum in 2020.

    And then you woke up.

    As has been said before, the survival of the Tory Party now depends on Brexit happening. It would be like a Labour government being elected and abolishing the NHS, or a Ukip government joining the EU. It is in the DNA.
    Very true. While of course no dealing will destroy them as an electoral force for time to come. Great croquet parties though to look forward to.
    The one good thing about Brexit is that every possible outcome results in the destruction of the Conservative and Unionist Party. The problem is, their replacement may be even worse.
  • Options
    Philip_ThompsonPhilip_Thompson Posts: 65,826

    Tory recovery plan:

    - Snap election in September.
    - Big majority for Boris.
    - Second referendum in 2020.

    Why would they bother with #3?
    This is williamglenn, he's a broken record.

    We could actually no deal exit on 31 October and he would on 1 November still be talking up a second referendum.
    At least he isn't talking up war with our European allies.
    Neither was I. I was saying that what eek ludicrously proposed was the EU declaring war, to which we would have to respond - which then got you muppets piling in on me like I was saying we should launch a pre-emptive nuclear strike.
    You talked of casus belli. It was the most ridiculous piece of jingoism I have seen in the whole of the Brexit debate, and that is saying something. We were not the muppets, you made a complete idiot of yourself and the cause that you seek to speak up for. You have made yourself a parody of a leaver, if that is even possible.
    No you have it backwards.

    I was ridiculing the preposterous suggestion that the EU would blockade the UK banning planes from flying, banning exports and imports. That would be a casus belli. It also won't happen.
  • Options
    RobDRobD Posts: 58,967

    RobD said:

    I wonder who May voted for.

    Odd that there were no spoilt ballot papers.

    I expected her to write her name in and then 'nothing has changed'.
    Imagine if Cheryl Gillian had announced "Theresa May: 1"

    :D
  • Options
    DecrepitJohnLDecrepitJohnL Posts: 13,300
    Lynton Crosby's plot to make Boris look competent in comparison?
  • Options
    algarkirkalgarkirk Posts: 10,534

    Continuity TIG?
    The Provisional Group for Continuity Independent Change could perhaps start an armed conflict by declaring war on South Cambridgeshire and Broxtowe.
  • Options
    PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 75,926
    MikeL said:

    Rules Question:

    What happens if Boris is the only person to get 33 votes in Round 2? Would he be declared winner or would top 2 still go to members?

    It's not actually that far off from happening - would only need Hunt and Gove to lose a few votes.

    If threshold in Round 2 had been 15% and not 10% then it easily could have happened!

    If that really happened, Boris would just be coronated
  • Options
    HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 116,995
    Certainly given the opposition parties will almost all never vote for a 'Tory' Withdrawal Agreement or for No Deal and the DUP will never vote for the backstop it is hard not to see how we do not have a general election
  • Options
    RH1992RH1992 Posts: 788
    RobD said:

    I wonder who May voted for.

    I'd like to think Stewart since he is the true "nothing has changed!" candidate.
  • Options
    DavidLDavidL Posts: 51,280
    RobD said:

    I wonder who May voted for.

    I would guess Hunt. He is continuity May far more than any of the others.
  • Options
    BarnesianBarnesian Posts: 7,989
    RobD said:

    I wonder who May voted for.

    Rory of course
  • Options
    Richard_NabaviRichard_Nabavi Posts: 30,820
    It's jolly decent of the TIGgers to have taken on the job of providing us with so much amusement in this worrying time.
  • Options
    ThomasNasheThomasNashe Posts: 4,971

    Tory recovery plan:

    - Snap election in September.
    - Big majority for Boris.
    - Second referendum in 2020.

    Why would they bother with #3?
    To get off the hook for delivering Brexit.
    Your dreaming if you think that will happen. If Boris wins a massive majority on the basis on getting Brexit through, they aren't going to go for a second referendum.
    The most accurate way to predict the future is to start from the assumption that Brexit won't happen, and then work backwards from there to fit the current circumstances. ;)
    Boris winning a big majority ain't going to happen. The Tories under Boris absolute best case is scraping a majority with the combination of those who want Brexit and the never Corbyn's, with just the correct amount of Labour voters splitting to Lib Dems because of Jezza's fence sitting.
    It'll not just be Labour remainers going to the Lib Dems though. There'll be a lot of Tory remainers heading that way too.
  • Options
    IanB2IanB2 Posts: 47,274
    edited June 2019

    Tory recovery plan:

    - Snap election in September.
    - Big majority for Boris.
    - Second referendum in 2020.

    Why would they bother with #3?
    To get off the hook for delivering Brexit.
    Your dreaming if you think that will happen. If Boris wins a massive majority on the basis on getting Brexit through, they aren't going to go for a second referendum.
    The most accurate way to predict the future is to start from the assumption that Brexit won't happen, and then work backwards from there to fit the current circumstances. ;)
    Boris winning a big majority ain't going to happen. The Tories under Boris absolute best case is scraping a majority with the combination of those who want Brexit and the never Corbyn's, with just the correct amount of Labour voters splitting to Lib Dems because of Jezza's fence sitting.
    Whereupon another ten Tory remainers emerge and we are back to square one.

    And the ERG won’t vote for a no deal exit because it isn’t no deal enough....
  • Options
    DecrepitJohnLDecrepitJohnL Posts: 13,300
    RobD said:

    I wonder who May voted for.

    Boris was Theresa May's first choice as Foreign Secretary.
  • Options
    JonathanJonathan Posts: 20,901
    Boris Brown.
  • Options
    RobDRobD Posts: 58,967

    RobD said:

    I wonder who May voted for.

    Boris was Theresa May's first choice as Foreign Secretary.
    I think she wanted to see him crash and burn. :p
  • Options
    RoyalBlueRoyalBlue Posts: 3,223
    Pulpstar said:

    MikeL said:

    Rules Question:

    What happens if Boris is the only person to get 33 votes in Round 2? Would he be declared winner or would top 2 still go to members?

    It's not actually that far off from happening - would only need Hunt and Gove to lose a few votes.

    If threshold in Round 2 had been 15% and not 10% then it easily could have happened!

    If that really happened, Boris would just be coronated
    CROWNED DAMMIT
  • Options
    Wulfrun_PhilWulfrun_Phil Posts: 4,600

    Tory recovery plan:

    - Snap election in September.
    - Big majority for Boris.
    - Second referendum in 2020.

    Why would they bother with #3?
    To get off the hook for delivering Brexit.
    Your dreaming if you think that will happen. If Boris wins a massive majority on the basis on getting Brexit through, they aren't going to go for a second referendum.
    The most accurate way to predict the future is to start from the assumption that Brexit won't happen, and then work backwards from there to fit the current circumstances. ;)
    Boris winning a big majority ain't going to happen. The Tories under Boris absolute best case is scraping a majority with the combination of those who want Brexit and the never Corbyn's, with just the correct amount of Labour voters splitting to Lib Dems because of Jezza's fence sitting.
    The only published poll so far gave the Conservatives a majority of 140 under Johnson. Now there are a number of reasons why you may be sceptical that that is the most probable outcome, and I think most of us here would view that as tending towards an extreme of a wide variety of possible outcomes. However, in the face of such evidence you are just closing your eyes to the facts if you claim that the "absolute best case" is the Conservatives scraping a majority under Johnson.
  • Options
    Philip_ThompsonPhilip_Thompson Posts: 65,826
    MikeL said:

    Rules Question:

    What happens if Boris is the only person to get 33 votes in Round 2? Would he be declared winner or would top 2 still go to members?

    It's not actually that far off from happening - would only need Hunt and Gove to lose a few votes.

    If threshold in Round 2 had been 15% and not 10% then it easily could have happened!

    It won't happen but if it did I believe he would be winner. The rule is anyone under 33 is eliminated. If everyone bar one is eliminated then the one must be the winner as per the precedent from Leadsom withdrawing.
  • Options
    ThomasNasheThomasNashe Posts: 4,971
    Cyclefree said:

    chloe said:

    TGOHF said:

    chloe said:

    Can’t see how Boris is going to be any more successful than May in resolving Brexit.

    May is a terrible politician.

    Boris's team just needs to be average.
    I hope he is better at being PM than he was Foreign Secretary.
    I think we can safely assume he won’t be.

    He is untrustworthy, a liar, afraid of scrutiny, a bit of a bully (expecting photos of the votes for him has a hint of G. Brown-style menace ), incompetent, frivolous and is not respected. He simply is not serious or thoughtful.

    His election as leader will neutralise many of the attacks that could be made against Corbyn and his move towards Brexit and even the contemplation of shutting down Parliament will alienate many of those who voted for him in the past.

    If the Tories choose him it simply shows that they are no longer a serious party, that old-fashioned, sensible Conservatism is dead and that they put the interests of their own party above those of the country.

    The Tories are not thinking straight. Choosing Boris is simply them indulging in a group hug. (A much more vulgar term would be more accurate but it is still early and this is a respectable site.)

    As Eddie Mair memorably, and rightly, said he's a nasty piece of work.
  • Options
    RobDRobD Posts: 58,967

    Tory recovery plan:

    - Snap election in September.
    - Big majority for Boris.
    - Second referendum in 2020.

    Why would they bother with #3?
    To get off the hook for delivering Brexit.
    Your dreaming if you think that will happen. If Boris wins a massive majority on the basis on getting Brexit through, they aren't going to go for a second referendum.
    The most accurate way to predict the future is to start from the assumption that Brexit won't happen, and then work backwards from there to fit the current circumstances. ;)
    Boris winning a big majority ain't going to happen. The Tories under Boris absolute best case is scraping a majority with the combination of those who want Brexit and the never Corbyn's, with just the correct amount of Labour voters splitting to Lib Dems because of Jezza's fence sitting.
    The only published poll so far gave the Conservatives a majority of 140 under Johnson. Now there are a number of reasons why you may be sceptical that that is the most probable outcome, and I think most of us here would view that as tending towards an extreme of a wide variety of possible outcomes. However, in the face of such evidence you are just closing your eyes to the facts if you claim that the "absolute best case" is the Conservatives scraping a majority under Johnson.
    I thought the consensus on here was that polls about hypotheticals are rarely worth the paper they are written on.
  • Options
    maaarshmaaarsh Posts: 3,391
    Endillion said:

    Tory recovery plan:

    - Snap election in September.
    - Big majority for Boris.
    - Second referendum in 2020.

    Why on earth does he call for a second referendum if he's just won a mandate for his preferred form of Brexit?
    Because until shown otherwise, remainers will assume that brexit is undeliverable and treat that as axiomatic in their predictions.
  • Options
    HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 116,995
    edited June 2019
    Looking at the numbers I think Raab could come second after the next ballot given that of the eliminated candidates today most of McVey and Leadsom's support will probably go to him and Boris and combined that makes 20 votes and Raab was only 16 votes behind second placed Hunt and 10 votes behind 3rd placed Gove in today's first ballot. Harper's support likely goes in multiple directions.


    It is also likely Hancock on 20 votes today and Javid on 23 will be eliminated in the next round too and fail to clear the 33 votes hurdle along probably with Stewart on 19 votes today (unless he really picks up momentum).


    That leaves Boris, Raab, Hunt and Gove as the final 4 and assuming most of Hancock and Stewart's votes go to Hunt and most of Javid's votes go to Raab where Gove's votes go after he is eliminated will be decisive in determining which of Raab and Hunt faces Boris in the membership ballot runoff after the final round
  • Options
    rottenboroughrottenborough Posts: 58,216

    Cyclefree said:

    chloe said:

    TGOHF said:

    chloe said:

    Can’t see how Boris is going to be any more successful than May in resolving Brexit.

    May is a terrible politician.

    Boris's team just needs to be average.
    I hope he is better at being PM than he was Foreign Secretary.
    I think we can safely assume he won’t be.

    He is untrustworthy, a liar, afraid of scrutiny, a bit of a bully (expecting photos of the votes for him has a hint of G. Brown-style menace ), incompetent, frivolous and is not respected. He simply is not serious or thoughtful.

    His election as leader will neutralise many of the attacks that could be made against Corbyn and his move towards Brexit and even the contemplation of shutting down Parliament will alienate many of those who voted for him in the past.

    If the Tories choose him it simply shows that they are no longer a serious party, that old-fashioned, sensible Conservatism is dead and that they put the interests of their own party above those of the country.

    The Tories are not thinking straight. Choosing Boris is simply them indulging in a group hug. (A much more vulgar term would be more accurate but it is still early and this is a respectable site.)

    As Eddie Mair memorably, and rightly, said he's a nasty piece of work.
    And quite likely imho not to actual become PM. He will not command confidence etc etc
  • Options
    BarnesianBarnesian Posts: 7,989

    Tory recovery plan:

    - Snap election in September.
    - Big majority for Boris.
    - Second referendum in 2020.

    Why would they bother with #3?
    To get off the hook for delivering Brexit.
    Your dreaming if you think that will happen. If Boris wins a massive majority on the basis on getting Brexit through, they aren't going to go for a second referendum.
    The most accurate way to predict the future is to start from the assumption that Brexit won't happen, and then work backwards from there to fit the current circumstances. ;)
    Boris winning a big majority ain't going to happen. The Tories under Boris absolute best case is scraping a majority with the combination of those who want Brexit and the never Corbyn's, with just the correct amount of Labour voters splitting to Lib Dems because of Jezza's fence sitting.
    Yes. If Boris has No Deal in lights in his manifesto, he'll shed many Tory Remainers to LibDems or even Green. If he doesn't have "No Deal;" up there, Farage will come for him as untrustworthy and the Brexit Party will steal important votes from the Tories. They are still in the bind.
  • Options
    IanB2IanB2 Posts: 47,274
    edited June 2019

    Tory recovery plan:

    - Snap election in September.
    - Big majority for Boris.
    - Second referendum in 2020.

    Why would they bother with #3?
    To get off the hook for delivering Brexit.
    Your dreaming if you think that will happen. If Boris wins a massive majority on the basis on getting Brexit through, they aren't going to go for a second referendum.
    The most accurate way to predict the future is to start from the assumption that Brexit won't happen, and then work backwards from there to fit the current circumstances. ;)
    Boris winning a big majority ain't going to happen. The Tories under Boris absolute best case is scraping a majority with the combination of those who want Brexit and the never Corbyn's, with just the correct amount of Labour voters splitting to Lib Dems because of Jezza's fence sitting.
    The only published poll so far gave the Conservatives a majority of 140 under Johnson. Now there are a number of reasons why you may be sceptical that that is the most probable outcome, and I think most of us here would view that as tending towards an extreme of a wide variety of possible outcomes. However, in the face of such evidence you are just closing your eyes to the facts if you claim that the "absolute best case" is the Conservatives scraping a majority under Johnson.
    The assumptions beneath that projection are obvious nonsense. The LibDems aren’t going to near treble their national vote by merrily adding the same percentage in every seat. On those percentages the LibDems will be sweeping Tories away through much of the Home Counties and South West.
  • Options
    rottenboroughrottenborough Posts: 58,216
    HYUFD said:

    Looking at the numbers I think Raab could come second after the next ballot given that of the eliminated candidates today most of McVey and Leadsom's support will probably go to him and Boris and combined that makes 20 votes and Raab was only 16 votes behind second placed Hunt and 10 votes behind 3rd placed Gove in today's first ballot.


    It is also likely Hancock on 20 votes today and Javid on 23 will be eliminated in the next round too and fail to clear the 33 votes hurdle along probably with Stewart on 19 votes today (unless he really picks up momentum).


    That leaves Boris, Raab, Hunt and Gove as the final 4 and assuming most of Hancock and Stewart's votes go to Hunt and most of Javid's votes go to Raab where Gove's votes go after he is eliminated will be decisive in determining which of Raab and Hunt faces Boris in the membership ballot runoff after the final round

    Javid's votes go to Raab?
  • Options
    DecrepitJohnLDecrepitJohnL Posts: 13,300
    DavidL said:

    RobD said:

    I wonder who May voted for.

    I would guess Hunt. He is continuity May far more than any of the others.
    Is it Hunt or Gove who is continuity May? Gove has shifted a long way to the soft side since fronting Leave in the referendum. Like May, he opposed both crashing out and a second referendum. And is there not something Govesque in the prime minister's recent conversion to zero emissions?
  • Options
    TheScreamingEaglesTheScreamingEagles Posts: 114,426
    RobD said:

    Tory recovery plan:

    - Snap election in September.
    - Big majority for Boris.
    - Second referendum in 2020.

    Why would they bother with #3?
    To get off the hook for delivering Brexit.
    Your dreaming if you think that will happen. If Boris wins a massive majority on the basis on getting Brexit through, they aren't going to go for a second referendum.
    The most accurate way to predict the future is to start from the assumption that Brexit won't happen, and then work backwards from there to fit the current circumstances. ;)
    Boris winning a big majority ain't going to happen. The Tories under Boris absolute best case is scraping a majority with the combination of those who want Brexit and the never Corbyn's, with just the correct amount of Labour voters splitting to Lib Dems because of Jezza's fence sitting.
    The only published poll so far gave the Conservatives a majority of 140 under Johnson. Now there are a number of reasons why you may be sceptical that that is the most probable outcome, and I think most of us here would view that as tending towards an extreme of a wide variety of possible outcomes. However, in the face of such evidence you are just closing your eyes to the facts if you claim that the "absolute best case" is the Conservatives scraping a majority under Johnson.
    I thought the consensus on here was that polls about hypotheticals are rarely worth the paper they are written on.
    Indeed, back in early 2017 there was a poll that said if there was a general election and the Lib Dems had a policy to stop Brexit whilst Labour did not then the Lib Dems would finish ahead of Labour.

    A few months later those were the policies of the Lib Dems and Labour, the Lib Dems polled 7.4% and Labour polled 40%.
  • Options
    CyclefreeCyclefree Posts: 25,205

    Cyclefree said:

    chloe said:

    TGOHF said:

    chloe said:

    Can’t see how Boris is going to be any more successful than May in resolving Brexit.

    May is a terrible politician.

    Boris's team just needs to be average.
    I hope he is better at being PM than he was Foreign Secretary.
    I think we can safely assume he won’t be.

    He is untrustworthy, a liar, afraid of scrutiny, a bit of a bully (expecting photos of the votes for him has a hint of G. Brown-style menace ), incompetent, frivolous and is not respected. He simply is not serious or thoughtful.

    His election as leader will neutralise many of the attacks that could be made against Corbyn and his move towards Brexit and even the contemplation of shutting down Parliament will alienate many of those who voted for him in the past.

    If the Tories choose him it simply shows that they are no longer a serious party, that old-fashioned, sensible Conservatism is dead and that they put the interests of their own party above those of the country.

    The Tories are not thinking straight. Choosing Boris is simply them indulging in a group hug. (A much more vulgar term would be more accurate but it is still early and this is a respectable site.)

    As Eddie Mair memorably, and rightly, said he's a nasty piece of work.

    Yes: nasty and incompetent. For all the superficial bonhomie and jolly japes persona, he is a bit like Corbyn in that respect. Corbyn seems polite and would no doubt be nice to chat to about gardening and such like. But there is an unpleasant side to him too eg not bothering to speak to Luciana Berger.

    What a dreadful choice. I will not vote for either.

    I am resigning myself to the fact that Britain is embarking on a serious of foolish choices which will do great harm to us. I only hope that the hole is not too deep before we start digging ourselves out of it.
  • Options
    RobDRobD Posts: 58,967
    GIN1138 said:
    Finally, the police are investigating real crimes.

    :p
  • Options
    HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 116,995
    IanB2 said:

    Tory recovery plan:

    - Snap election in September.
    - Big majority for Boris.
    - Second referendum in 2020.

    Why would they bother with #3?
    To get off the hook for delivering Brexit.
    Your dreaming if you think that will happen. If Boris wins a massive majority on the basis on getting Brexit through, they aren't going to go for a second referendum.
    The most accurate way to predict the future is to start from the assumption that Brexit won't happen, and then work backwards from there to fit the current circumstances. ;)
    Boris winning a big majority ain't going to happen. The Tories under Boris absolute best case is scraping a majority with the combination of those who want Brexit and the never Corbyn's, with just the correct amount of Labour voters splitting to Lib Dems because of Jezza's fence sitting.
    The only published poll so far gave the Conservatives a majority of 140 under Johnson. Now there are a number of reasons why you may be sceptical that that is the most probable outcome, and I think most of us here would view that as tending towards an extreme of a wide variety of possible outcomes. However, in the face of such evidence you are just closing your eyes to the facts if you claim that the "absolute best case" is the Conservatives scraping a majority under Johnson.
    The assumptions beneath that projection are obvious nonsense. The LibDems aren’t going to near treble their national vote by merrily adding the same percentage in every seat. On those percentages the LibDems will be sweeping Tories away through much of the Home Counties and South West.
    While the Tories sweep Labour away in much of the North and Midlands
  • Options
    HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 116,995

    HYUFD said:

    Looking at the numbers I think Raab could come second after the next ballot given that of the eliminated candidates today most of McVey and Leadsom's support will probably go to him and Boris and combined that makes 20 votes and Raab was only 16 votes behind second placed Hunt and 10 votes behind 3rd placed Gove in today's first ballot.


    It is also likely Hancock on 20 votes today and Javid on 23 will be eliminated in the next round too and fail to clear the 33 votes hurdle along probably with Stewart on 19 votes today (unless he really picks up momentum).


    That leaves Boris, Raab, Hunt and Gove as the final 4 and assuming most of Hancock and Stewart's votes go to Hunt and most of Javid's votes go to Raab where Gove's votes go after he is eliminated will be decisive in determining which of Raab and Hunt faces Boris in the membership ballot runoff after the final round

    Javid's votes go to Raab?
    Likely, Javid backs leaving in October Deal or No Deal like Raab and unlike Hunt or Gove
  • Options
    ThomasNasheThomasNashe Posts: 4,971
    IanB2 said:

    Tory recovery plan:

    - Snap election in September.
    - Big majority for Boris.
    - Second referendum in 2020.

    Why would they bother with #3?
    To get off the hook for delivering Brexit.
    Your dreaming if you think that will happen. If Boris wins a massive majority on the basis on getting Brexit through, they aren't going to go for a second referendum.
    The most accurate way to predict the future is to start from the assumption that Brexit won't happen, and then work backwards from there to fit the current circumstances. ;)
    Boris winning a big majority ain't going to happen. The Tories under Boris absolute best case is scraping a majority with the combination of those who want Brexit and the never Corbyn's, with just the correct amount of Labour voters splitting to Lib Dems because of Jezza's fence sitting.
    The only published poll so far gave the Conservatives a majority of 140 under Johnson. Now there are a number of reasons why you may be sceptical that that is the most probable outcome, and I think most of us here would view that as tending towards an extreme of a wide variety of possible outcomes. However, in the face of such evidence you are just closing your eyes to the facts if you claim that the "absolute best case" is the Conservatives scraping a majority under Johnson.
    The assumptions beneath that projection are obvious nonsense. The LibDems aren’t going to near treble their national vote by merrily adding the same percentage in every seat. On those percentages the LibDems will be sweeping Tories away through much of the Home Counties and South West.
    I agree. I also suspect some of their most spectacular gains will come in London.
  • Options
    CyclefreeCyclefree Posts: 25,205

    Cyclefree said:

    chloe said:

    TGOHF said:

    chloe said:

    Can’t see how Boris is going to be any more successful than May in resolving Brexit.

    May is a terrible politician.

    Boris's team just needs to be average.
    I hope he is better at being PM than he was Foreign Secretary.
    I think we can safely assume he won’t be.

    He is untrustworthy, a liar, afraid of scrutiny, a bit of a bully (expecting photos of the votes for him has a hint of G. Brown-style menace ), incompetent, frivolous and is not respected. He simply is not serious or thoughtful.

    His election as leader will neutralise many of the attacks that could be made against Corbyn and his move towards Brexit and even the contemplation of shutting down Parliament will alienate many of those who voted for him in the past.

    If the Tories choose him it simply shows that they are no longer a serious party, that old-fashioned, sensible Conservatism is dead and that they put the interests of their own party above those of the country.

    The Tories are not thinking straight. Choosing Boris is simply them indulging in a group hug. (A much more vulgar term would be more accurate but it is still early and this is a respectable site.)

    As Eddie Mair memorably, and rightly, said he's a nasty piece of work.
    And quite likely imho not to actual become PM. He will not command confidence etc etc
    I’m not so sure. I suspect that tribal loyalty will override any claims of conscience. Unfortunately.
  • Options
    Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 55,329
    The centrists and centre-lefties backing Rory?

    Thanks. I’m on the other side of that bet.
  • Options
    RobDRobD Posts: 58,967
    Interesting that the first debate is before the second ballot of MPs. I wonder how much that will affect things?
  • Options
    EndillionEndillion Posts: 4,976
    RoyalBlue said:

    Pulpstar said:

    MikeL said:

    Rules Question:

    What happens if Boris is the only person to get 33 votes in Round 2? Would he be declared winner or would top 2 still go to members?

    It's not actually that far off from happening - would only need Hunt and Gove to lose a few votes.

    If threshold in Round 2 had been 15% and not 10% then it easily could have happened!

    If that really happened, Boris would just be coronated
    CROWNED DAMMIT
    Push!
  • Options
    ThomasNasheThomasNashe Posts: 4,971
    Cyclefree said:

    Cyclefree said:

    chloe said:

    TGOHF said:

    chloe said:

    Can’t see how Boris is going to be any more successful than May in resolving Brexit.

    May is a terrible politician.

    Boris's team just needs to be average.
    I hope he is better at being PM than he was Foreign Secretary.
    I think we can safely assume he won’t be.

    He is untrustworthy, a liar, afraid of scrutiny, a bit of a bully (expecting photos of the votes for him has a hint of G. Brown-style menace ), incompetent, frivolous and is not respected. He simply is not serious or thoughtful.

    His election as leader will neutralise many of the attacks that could be made against Corbyn and his move towards Brexit and even the contemplation of shutting down Parliament will alienate many of those who voted for him in the past.

    If the Tories choose him it simply shows that they are no longer a serious party, that old-fashioned, sensible Conservatism is dead and that they put the interests of their own party above those of the country.

    The Tories are not thinking straight. Choosing Boris is simply them indulging in a group hug. (A much more vulgar term would be more accurate but it is still early and this is a respectable site.)

    As Eddie Mair memorably, and rightly, said he's a nasty piece of work.

    Yes: nasty and incompetent. For all the superficial bonhomie and jolly japes persona, he is a bit like Corbyn in that respect. Corbyn seems polite and would no doubt be nice to chat to about gardening and such like. But there is an unpleasant side to him too eg not bothering to speak to Luciana Berger.

    What a dreadful choice. I will not vote for either.

    I am resigning myself to the fact that Britain is embarking on a serious of foolish choices which will do great harm to us. I only hope that the hole is not too deep before we start digging ourselves out of it.
    Agree. I'm a lifelong (every GE since 1983) Labour voter, firmly in the Lib-Dem camp now.
  • Options
    OldKingColeOldKingCole Posts: 31,983
    GIN1138 said:
    Well, it was a damn silly thing to say.

    But if May cared a bit more about the cruel elements of her Governments policy her complaints would perhaps be taken more seriously.
  • Options
    viewcodeviewcode Posts: 18,758
    Endillion said:

    RoyalBlue said:

    Pulpstar said:

    MikeL said:

    Rules Question:

    What happens if Boris is the only person to get 33 votes in Round 2? Would he be declared winner or would top 2 still go to members?

    It's not actually that far off from happening - would only need Hunt and Gove to lose a few votes.

    If threshold in Round 2 had been 15% and not 10% then it easily could have happened!

    If that really happened, Boris would just be coronated
    CROWNED DAMMIT
    Push!
    I can see the baby's head!
  • Options
    IanB2IanB2 Posts: 47,274
    edited June 2019
    HYUFD said:

    IanB2 said:

    Tory recovery plan:

    - Snap election in September.
    - Big majority for Boris.
    - Second referendum in 2020.

    Why would they bother with #3?
    To get off the hook for delivering Brexit.
    Your dreaming if you think that will happen. If Boris wins a massive majority on the basis on getting Brexit through, they aren't going to go for a second referendum.
    The most accurate way to predict the future is to start from the assumption that Brexit won't happen, and then work backwards from there to fit the current circumstances. ;)
    Boris winning a big majority ain't going to happen. The Tories under Boris absolute best case is scraping a majority with the combination of those who want Brexit and the never Corbyn's, with just the correct amount of Labour voters splitting to Lib Dems because of Jezza's fence sitting.
    The only published poll so far gave the Conservatives a majority of 140 under Johnson. Now there are a number of reasons why you may be sceptical that that is the most probable outcome, and I think most of us here would view that as tending towards an extreme of a wide variety of possible outcomes. However, in the face of such evidence you are just closing your eyes to the facts if you claim that the "absolute best case" is the Conservatives scraping a majority under Johnson.
    The assumptions beneath that projection are obvious nonsense. The LibDems aren’t going to near treble their national vote by merrily adding the same percentage in every seat. On those percentages the LibDems will be sweeping Tories away through much of the Home Counties and South West.
    While the Tories sweep Labour away in much of the North and Midlands
    Labour falling back by a higher percentage in the remainer South East would mean that - for the same national vote share - its vote will hold up better elsewhere. We are wasting our time trying to put current opinion polls through a UNS seat calculator.
  • Options
    Wulfrun_PhilWulfrun_Phil Posts: 4,600
    MikeL said:

    Rules Question:

    What happens if Boris is the only person to get 33 votes in Round 2? Would he be declared winner or would top 2 still go to members?

    It's not actually that far off from happening - would only need Hunt and Gove to lose a few votes.

    If threshold in Round 2 had been 15% and not 10% then it easily could have happened!

    It is not inconceivable that all the other candidates could withdraw, as happened in 2016. It would still be in Johnson's interest in terms of strengthening his authority to ask the 1922 to declare him leader such that he was able to take over as PM and start proper preparations for leaving on 31st October but to request that they also instigate a confirmatory ballot of members.

    When she hit the rocks after 2017, May's authority was weakened by the absence of a members' ballot.
  • Options
    RobDRobD Posts: 58,967

    GIN1138 said:
    Well, it was a damn silly thing to say.

    But if May cared a bit more about the cruel elements of her Governments policy her complaints would perhaps be taken more seriously.
    Ah, Tories are evil so Brand can say what she wants? OK.
  • Options
    DecrepitJohnLDecrepitJohnL Posts: 13,300
    RobD said:

    Interesting that the first debate is before the second ballot of MPs. I wonder how much that will affect things?

    In the debate, Hunt should simply stand up and tell MPs to consider which of Boris and Hunt was the best Foreign Secretary. Then we can clean up on William Hague write-ins.
This discussion has been closed.