Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

Options

politicalbetting.com » Blog Archive » Punters now make it a 63% chance that the UK will leave the EU

SystemSystem Posts: 11,006
edited June 2018 in General

imagepoliticalbetting.com » Blog Archive » Punters now make it a 63% chance that the UK will leave the EU on March 29th next year

Betdata.io

Read the full story here


«13

Comments

  • Options
    tlg86tlg86 Posts: 25,187
    First
  • Options
    Tim_BTim_B Posts: 7,669
    2nd
  • Options
    Sean_FSean_F Posts: 35,789

    I can't see how any legal case to stop Brexit would succeed, now that Parliament has passed legislation to exercise A50, and passed the withdrawal Bill.
  • Options
    Big_G_NorthWalesBig_G_NorthWales Posts: 60,247
    Have a good wedding

    And no - Brexit will not be stopped by legal challenges - far too late
  • Options
    Philip_ThompsonPhilip_Thompson Posts: 65,826
    There can't be court cases against Brexit because of R (Miller) v Secretary of State for Exiting the European Union [2017]

    The law is crystal clear that we're exiting the EU because of an Act of Parliament not the referendum and it will take another Act of Parliament to reverse that.
  • Options
    RobDRobD Posts: 58,961

    There can't be court cases against Brexit because of R (Miller) v Secretary of State for Exiting the European Union [2017]

    The law is crystal clear that we're exiting the EU because of an Act of Parliament not the referendum and it will take another Act of Parliament to reverse that.

    Ironic...
  • Options
    AlastairMeeksAlastairMeeks Posts: 30,340
    My favourite market of the last year.

    For what it's worth I'd have thought there's no better than a 1 in 6 chance of the date being put back, and probably much lower than that.
  • Options
    AndyJSAndyJS Posts: 29,395
    edited June 2018
    I wonder whether a possible change of leadership in Germany might cause Brexit to be delayed in a way that no-one is currently predicting.
  • Options
    ElliotElliot Posts: 1,516

    Mr. Nick, if it's impossible, why was Varadkar's predecessor working with us on it?

    The UK government needs to hammer this point home every day.
  • Options
    MarqueeMarkMarqueeMark Posts: 50,095
    Quality goal!
  • Options
    FrancisUrquhartFrancisUrquhart Posts: 76,274
    St Paul's Girls' School 'Austerity Day' criticised

    http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-london-44578499

    Can’t win...if they did nothing they would be criticised be for out of touch, if they served crap, they would be criticised for serving unhealthy stuff to kids, ....
  • Options
    brendan16brendan16 Posts: 2,315

    Have a good wedding

    And no - Brexit will not be stopped by legal challenges - far too late

    And certainly not because of an investigation into spending by the leave campaign or its offshoots by the Electoral Commission when remain (including HM govt) reportedly spent about £15 million more on its campaign. If there had truly been a fair campaign money wise leave would probably have won
    by more.
  • Options
    ElliotElliot Posts: 1,516

    This is that moment in Lord of the Rings when Elrond notes our list of allies grows thin

    Bad comparison. Elrond was on the side of the enlightened.
    Can't have been that enlightened. Lists get longer or shorter, not thinner.
  • Options
    brendan16brendan16 Posts: 2,315

    There can't be court cases against Brexit because of R (Miller) v Secretary of State for Exiting the European Union [2017]

    The law is crystal clear that we're exiting the EU because of an Act of Parliament not the referendum and it will take another Act of Parliament to reverse that.

    Hedge fund Gina deserves a great deal of thanks for helping to secure Brexit!
  • Options
    notmenotme Posts: 3,293

    St Paul's Girls' School 'Austerity Day' criticised

    http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-london-44578499

    Can’t win...if they did nothing they would be criticised be for out of touch, if they served crap, they would be criticised for serving unhealthy stuff to kids, ....

    the reality is that school dinners are not crap... Other than due to pressure theyve actively reduced the best parts, fat, sugar and salt.

    But is baked potato coleslaw and beans really slumming it?
  • Options
    ElliotElliot Posts: 1,516
    Does the UK export more autoparts to the EU than the other way round? That is what will define whihc sector grows more.
  • Options
    ElliotElliot Posts: 1,516
    Bertie Ahern:

    "I'm not saying we can finish it all by June, but if we are to drag it out until the end, the British could come in the last few days with their €50 billion cheque and say: ‘We’re going to do this and we’re going to do that, and going to do the other’.

    "And they’ll say to the French and the Germans who are making the running on this, we’ve given the Irish a lot, now is the time for the Irish to move, and the pressure will come back on us."

    The Irish know they are in danger of overplaying their hand.
  • Options
    kle4kle4 Posts: 91,625
    edited June 2018
    brendan16 said:

    There can't be court cases against Brexit because of R (Miller) v Secretary of State for Exiting the European Union [2017]

    The law is crystal clear that we're exiting the EU because of an Act of Parliament not the referendum and it will take another Act of Parliament to reverse that.

    Hedge fund Gina deserves a great deal of thanks for helping to secure Brexit!
    I think she deserves thanks for bringing what was a worthy case, regardless of it helping to secure Brexit or not. OGH is I think getting a little excited, considering elections are not automatically invalidated entirely because of financial irregularities (which should be punished, the rules are the rules after all), and that as any number of people on either side have pointed out to their advantage at times, the referendum was advisory. Of course it was the reason the Act was passed, but it's now up to the MPs to decide to repeal it if they think this news undermines the reason they voted for the Act in the first place.
  • Options
    ralphmalphralphmalph Posts: 2,201
    Elliot said:

    Does the UK export more autoparts to the EU than the other way round? That is what will define whihc sector grows more.

    We import in 2016 12.2B USD export 4.4B USD.
  • Options
    ElliotElliot Posts: 1,516

    Elliot said:

    Does the UK export more autoparts to the EU than the other way round? That is what will define whihc sector grows more.

    We import in 2016 12.2B USD export 4.4B USD.
    So if border friction forces consolidated supply chains the UK is likely to gain automotive activity on net, even if it causes a bit of reduction of total production overall.
  • Options
    Philip_ThompsonPhilip_Thompson Posts: 65,826
    Shame there aren't more nuanced polls more often. Where is "less unskilled migration but more and easier skilled migration" as an option?

    We currently have a cap on skilled non-EU migration (including doctors etc) but no cap on EU migration regardless of skills. Nobody ever surveys whether having no cap at all on skilled migration (from EU and non-EU both) is a good idea.
  • Options
    rcs1000rcs1000 Posts: 53,920
    brendan16 said:

    There can't be court cases against Brexit because of R (Miller) v Secretary of State for Exiting the European Union [2017]

    The law is crystal clear that we're exiting the EU because of an Act of Parliament not the referendum and it will take another Act of Parliament to reverse that.

    Hedge fund Gina deserves a great deal of thanks for helping to secure Brexit!
    As predicted by me at the time (polishes nails).
  • Options
    ralphmalphralphmalph Posts: 2,201
    Elliot said:

    Elliot said:

    Does the UK export more autoparts to the EU than the other way round? That is what will define whihc sector grows more.

    We import in 2016 12.2B USD export 4.4B USD.
    So if border friction forces consolidated supply chains the UK is likely to gain automotive activity on net, even if it causes a bit of reduction of total production overall.
    Not border friction, but price, rules of origin and the fact that the ideal location for a head of manufacturing at a car company for their suppliers is in a 1 mile circle around the car factory.
  • Options
    RobDRobD Posts: 58,961
    Scott_P said:

    twitter.com/thetimes/status/1010198479363244032

    The fact that China and the US are mentioned before elsewhere in the EU is telling.
  • Options
    Morris_DancerMorris_Dancer Posts: 60,969
    Hope the wedding is splendid :)
  • Options
    AndyJSAndyJS Posts: 29,395
    Not good enough from Iceland.
  • Options
    CarlottaVanceCarlottaVance Posts: 59,572
    RobD said:

    Scott_P said:

    twitter.com/thetimes/status/1010198479363244032

    The fact that China and the US are mentioned before elsewhere in the EU is telling.
    If anyone should be upset it’s Hamburg - looks like 320 wing assembly isn’t going there as they’ve been angling for for years....
  • Options
    CarlottaVanceCarlottaVance Posts: 59,572
    More testimony to the sound sense of the British:

    https://twitter.com/YouGov/status/1010198002991075328?s=20
  • Options
    NigelbNigelb Posts: 62,351

    More testimony to the sound sense of the British:

    https://twitter.com/YouGov/status/1010198002991075328?s=20

    I don't know... Trump can be inspirational from time to time.

    Just not in a good way.
  • Options
    Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 55,267
    edited June 2018

    St Paul's Girls' School 'Austerity Day' criticised

    http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-london-44578499

    Can’t win...if they did nothing they would be criticised be for out of touch, if they served crap, they would be criticised for serving unhealthy stuff to kids, ....

    I can see precisely nothing wrong with this.

    I think the offence is just being a private school.
  • Options
    CarlottaVanceCarlottaVance Posts: 59,572

    Shame there aren't more nuanced polls more often. Where is "less unskilled migration but more and easier skilled migration" as an option?

    We currently have a cap on skilled non-EU migration (including doctors etc) but no cap on EU migration regardless of skills. Nobody ever surveys whether having no cap at all on skilled migration (from EU and non-EU both) is a good idea.
    Surely to heavens our experience with EU negotiations so far has shown that it’s pointless to make “generous” offers (security, defence) - the EU simply banks them and says “more”. We should start from “Eu is a third country” (as they never tire of telling us we are) and say “any improvement contingent on trade deal” - rather than the fatuous “if we’re generous on immigration they’ll be nice to us on trade.”
  • Options
    Morris_DancerMorris_Dancer Posts: 60,969
    Miss Vance, with the exception of House of Cards (itself aping a UK TV programme/book), US depictions of fictional presidents tend to be inspirational. UK fictional PMs are largely villains or fools. Urquhart or Hacker.
  • Options
    kle4kle4 Posts: 91,625
    edited June 2018

    Miss Vance, with the exception of House of Cards (itself aping a UK TV programme/book), US depictions of fictional presidents tend to be inspirational. UK fictional PMs are largely villains or fools. Urquhart or Hacker.

    I'd say by the end of Yes Prime Minister Hacker was neither a villain nor a fool, though he could indeed be foolish. He had more steel in him, and wiliness, by the end.
  • Options
    another_richardanother_richard Posts: 25,046

    St Paul's Girls' School 'Austerity Day' criticised

    http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-london-44578499

    Can’t win...if they did nothing they would be criticised be for out of touch, if they served crap, they would be criticised for serving unhealthy stuff to kids, ....

    I can see precisely nothing wrong with this.

    I think the offence is just being a private school.
    Food is cheap in this country.

    The issue with austerity is housing costs.

    That might have been a better item for a west London school to focus upon.
  • Options
    another_richardanother_richard Posts: 25,046
    Today's Tesco Strawberry score is once again nine:

    Aberdeenshire
    Angus
    Perthshire
    Fife
    Nottinghamshire
    Staffordshire
    Norfolk
    Herefordshire
    Kent

    The only new point of interest is the increasing numbers of packs with yellow stickers on supply exceeding demand after months of the glut I suspect.
  • Options
    another_richardanother_richard Posts: 25,046
    Difficult to know what to believe any more but I don't expect Time magazine will be too concerned:

    ' A little girl who became the public face of US migrant family separations was not taken away from her mother at the US border, says her father.

    A photograph of the Honduran toddler sobbing in a pink jacket was taken at the scene of a border detention.

    Time magazine has used the image for its latest cover, depicting President Donald Trump looming over the girl with the caption: "Welcome to America".

    https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-44578339
  • Options
    NemtynakhtNemtynakht Posts: 2,311
    brendan16 said:

    Have a good wedding

    And no - Brexit will not be stopped by legal challenges - far too late

    And certainly not because of an investigation into spending by the leave campaign or its offshoots by the Electoral Commission when remain (including HM govt) reportedly spent about £15 million more on its campaign. If there had truly been a fair campaign money wise leave would probably have won
    by more.
    Remain had the benefit of incumbency, the organisation of the civil service behind it and donations from lots of high profile businesses. However this was fair as most people would understand it, as they were open about it, and to be honest I think the Leave campaign were able to play the underdog, anti establishment card.
  • Options
    BarnesianBarnesian Posts: 7,987
    Brexit will not be derailed by any legal stuff. That's pie in the sky.

    It could be derailed by a big switch in public opinion (which probably won't happen) that causes the PM and LOTO to reconsider their strategy.

    It could also be derailed by May procrastinating to the very end because of the contradictions in her position and threats from her cabinet. The process might simply run out of road and adults take over at the last moment in a constitutional crisis that will test the Queen and the Speaker.
  • Options
    Big_G_NorthWalesBig_G_NorthWales Posts: 60,247
    Barnesian said:

    Brexit will not be derailed by any legal stuff. That's pie in the sky.

    It could be derailed by a big switch in public opinion (which probably won't happen) that causes the PM and LOTO to reconsider their strategy.

    It could also be derailed by May procrastinating to the very end because of the contradictions in her position and threats from her cabinet. The process might simply run out of road and adults take over at the last moment in a constitutional crisis that will test the Queen and the Speaker.

    Interesting but who are your adults - genuine question
  • Options
    BarnesianBarnesian Posts: 7,987

    Barnesian said:

    Brexit will not be derailed by any legal stuff. That's pie in the sky.

    It could be derailed by a big switch in public opinion (which probably won't happen) that causes the PM and LOTO to reconsider their strategy.

    It could also be derailed by May procrastinating to the very end because of the contradictions in her position and threats from her cabinet. The process might simply run out of road and adults take over at the last moment in a constitutional crisis that will test the Queen and the Speaker.

    Interesting but who are your adults - genuine question
    Grieve, Hammond(P), Umanna, Starmer, Cable, Blackford.

    It would be a real crisis with the prospect of crashing out with no preparations and really dire consequences. It would be a national emergency - the scenario that keeps Grieve awake at night. There would be a vote of no confidence in the government with a temporary coalition of Remainer Tories, Labour, SNP and LIbDems to extend A50 and either agree a very soft Brexit and/or put options to a people's vote. The Queen would have to be assured that this grouping had the confidence of the House and the Speaker would have to facilitate it. It would be high drama.
  • Options
    rcs1000rcs1000 Posts: 53,920

    Barnesian said:

    Brexit will not be derailed by any legal stuff. That's pie in the sky.

    It could be derailed by a big switch in public opinion (which probably won't happen) that causes the PM and LOTO to reconsider their strategy.

    It could also be derailed by May procrastinating to the very end because of the contradictions in her position and threats from her cabinet. The process might simply run out of road and adults take over at the last moment in a constitutional crisis that will test the Queen and the Speaker.

    Interesting but who are your adults - genuine question
    I think the plan is for Juncker to stand at the next by-election in the UK. When he is elected with 99% of the vote, he then leads a revolt by pro-EU MPs, and becomes Prime Minister.

    In his dual roles, he puts Britain at the heart of Europe, and introduces the Euro to the UK. He is hailed by all as the greatest statesman of his age.
  • Options
    ydoethurydoethur Posts: 67,109
    rcs1000 said:

    Barnesian said:

    Brexit will not be derailed by any legal stuff. That's pie in the sky.

    It could be derailed by a big switch in public opinion (which probably won't happen) that causes the PM and LOTO to reconsider their strategy.

    It could also be derailed by May procrastinating to the very end because of the contradictions in her position and threats from her cabinet. The process might simply run out of road and adults take over at the last moment in a constitutional crisis that will test the Queen and the Speaker.

    Interesting but who are your adults - genuine question
    I think the plan is for Juncker to stand at the next by-election in the UK. When he is elected with 99% of the vote, he then leads a revolt by pro-EU MPs, and becomes Prime Minister.

    In his dual roles, he puts Britain at the heart of Europe, and introduces the Euro to the UK. He is hailed by all as the greatest statesman of his age.
    I assume in this scenario we all get free vodka to vote for him? Could work.
  • Options
    williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 48,011
    rcs1000 said:

    Barnesian said:

    Brexit will not be derailed by any legal stuff. That's pie in the sky.

    It could be derailed by a big switch in public opinion (which probably won't happen) that causes the PM and LOTO to reconsider their strategy.

    It could also be derailed by May procrastinating to the very end because of the contradictions in her position and threats from her cabinet. The process might simply run out of road and adults take over at the last moment in a constitutional crisis that will test the Queen and the Speaker.

    Interesting but who are your adults - genuine question
    I think the plan is for Juncker to stand at the next by-election in the UK. When he is elected with 99% of the vote, he then leads a revolt by pro-EU MPs, and becomes Prime Minister.

    In his dual roles, he puts Britain at the heart of Europe, and introduces the Euro to the UK. He is hailed by all as the greatest statesman of his age.
    Who added you to the whatsapp group?! ;)
  • Options
    Big_G_NorthWalesBig_G_NorthWales Posts: 60,247
    Barnesian said:

    Barnesian said:

    Brexit will not be derailed by any legal stuff. That's pie in the sky.

    It could be derailed by a big switch in public opinion (which probably won't happen) that causes the PM and LOTO to reconsider their strategy.

    It could also be derailed by May procrastinating to the very end because of the contradictions in her position and threats from her cabinet. The process might simply run out of road and adults take over at the last moment in a constitutional crisis that will test the Queen and the Speaker.

    Interesting but who are your adults - genuine question
    Grieve, Hammond(P), Umanna, Starmer, Cable, Blackford.

    It would be a real crisis with the prospect of crashing out with no preparations and really dire consequences. It would be a national emergency - the scenario that keeps Grieve awake at night. There would be a vote of no confidence in the government with a temporary coalition of Remainer Tories, Labour, SNP and LIbDems to extend A50 and either agree a very soft Brexit and/or put options to a people's vote. The Queen would have to be assured that this grouping had the confidence of the House and the Speaker would have to facilitate it. It would be high drama.
    Well they are all remainers and civil war would break out in politics. It needs someone who can command respect from both sides and at present I do not see anyone though that could change
  • Options
    Stark_DawningStark_Dawning Posts: 9,287
    As much as the Leavers would like some kind of legal challenge to derail Brexit this will not, and indeed should not, be allowed to happen. There must be no easy left off for those who orchestrated this mischief. We hear today that Farage is airily content to see British manufacturing put to the sword to facilitate his plans. I'd hate to see this happen myself, but 'the Will of the People' and all that. No, the Leavers have made their decision. Not seeing it through is the coward's way out.
  • Options
    Big_G_NorthWalesBig_G_NorthWales Posts: 60,247
    rcs1000 said:

    Barnesian said:

    Brexit will not be derailed by any legal stuff. That's pie in the sky.

    It could be derailed by a big switch in public opinion (which probably won't happen) that causes the PM and LOTO to reconsider their strategy.

    It could also be derailed by May procrastinating to the very end because of the contradictions in her position and threats from her cabinet. The process might simply run out of road and adults take over at the last moment in a constitutional crisis that will test the Queen and the Speaker.

    Interesting but who are your adults - genuine question
    I think the plan is for Juncker to stand at the next by-election in the UK. When he is elected with 99% of the vote, he then leads a revolt by pro-EU MPs, and becomes Prime Minister.

    In his dual roles, he puts Britain at the heart of Europe, and introduces the Euro to the UK. He is hailed by all as the greatest statesman of his age.
    That is some imagination
  • Options
    Big_G_NorthWalesBig_G_NorthWales Posts: 60,247

    As much as the Leavers would like some kind of legal challenge to derail Brexit this will not, and indeed should not, be allowed to happen. There must be no easy left off for those who orchestrated this mischief. We hear today that Farage is airily content to see British manufacturing put to the sword to facilitate his plans. I'd hate to see this happen myself, but 'the Will of the People' and all that. No, the Leavers have made their decision. Not seeing it through is the coward's way out.

    Are you sure you mean leavers in your first sentence
  • Options
    williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 48,011

    Barnesian said:

    Barnesian said:

    Brexit will not be derailed by any legal stuff. That's pie in the sky.

    It could be derailed by a big switch in public opinion (which probably won't happen) that causes the PM and LOTO to reconsider their strategy.

    It could also be derailed by May procrastinating to the very end because of the contradictions in her position and threats from her cabinet. The process might simply run out of road and adults take over at the last moment in a constitutional crisis that will test the Queen and the Speaker.

    Interesting but who are your adults - genuine question
    Grieve, Hammond(P), Umanna, Starmer, Cable, Blackford.

    It would be a real crisis with the prospect of crashing out with no preparations and really dire consequences. It would be a national emergency - the scenario that keeps Grieve awake at night. There would be a vote of no confidence in the government with a temporary coalition of Remainer Tories, Labour, SNP and LIbDems to extend A50 and either agree a very soft Brexit and/or put options to a people's vote. The Queen would have to be assured that this grouping had the confidence of the House and the Speaker would have to facilitate it. It would be high drama.
    Well they are all remainers and civil war would break out in politics. It needs someone who can command respect from both sides and at present I do not see anyone though that could change
    It can only be Ken Clarke in that case. Watch how he has Farage eating out of his hand.

    https://twitter.com/Haggis_UK/status/1010100142215761921
  • Options
    rcs1000rcs1000 Posts: 53,920

    rcs1000 said:

    Barnesian said:

    Brexit will not be derailed by any legal stuff. That's pie in the sky.

    It could be derailed by a big switch in public opinion (which probably won't happen) that causes the PM and LOTO to reconsider their strategy.

    It could also be derailed by May procrastinating to the very end because of the contradictions in her position and threats from her cabinet. The process might simply run out of road and adults take over at the last moment in a constitutional crisis that will test the Queen and the Speaker.

    Interesting but who are your adults - genuine question
    I think the plan is for Juncker to stand at the next by-election in the UK. When he is elected with 99% of the vote, he then leads a revolt by pro-EU MPs, and becomes Prime Minister.

    In his dual roles, he puts Britain at the heart of Europe, and introduces the Euro to the UK. He is hailed by all as the greatest statesman of his age.
    That is some imagination
    That's the plan. In reality, I suspect Juncker would struggle to top 95% in the by-election.
  • Options
    NemtynakhtNemtynakht Posts: 2,311

    Shame there aren't more nuanced polls more often. Where is "less unskilled migration but more and easier skilled migration" as an option?

    We currently have a cap on skilled non-EU migration (including doctors etc) but no cap on EU migration regardless of skills. Nobody ever surveys whether having no cap at all on skilled migration (from EU and non-EU both) is a good idea.
    Surely to heavens our experience with EU negotiations so far has shown that it’s pointless to make “generous” offers (security, defence) - the EU simply banks them and says “more”. We should start from “Eu is a third country” (as they never tire of telling us we are) and say “any improvement contingent on trade deal” - rather than the fatuous “if we’re generous on immigration they’ll be nice to us on trade.”
    If I were negotiating with the EU I would be leaving open the possibility of a second referendum. That would mean they would have to be more careful to court public opinion. At the moment we are not playing the advantages we do have. I would also be negotiating the no deal WTO situation as default - it would then mean that "things could only get better"
  • Options
    rcs1000rcs1000 Posts: 53,920

    Barnesian said:

    Barnesian said:

    Brexit will not be derailed by any legal stuff. That's pie in the sky.

    It could be derailed by a big switch in public opinion (which probably won't happen) that causes the PM and LOTO to reconsider their strategy.

    It could also be derailed by May procrastinating to the very end because of the contradictions in her position and threats from her cabinet. The process might simply run out of road and adults take over at the last moment in a constitutional crisis that will test the Queen and the Speaker.

    Interesting but who are your adults - genuine question
    Grieve, Hammond(P), Umanna, Starmer, Cable, Blackford.

    It would be a real crisis with the prospect of crashing out with no preparations and really dire consequences. It would be a national emergency - the scenario that keeps Grieve awake at night. There would be a vote of no confidence in the government with a temporary coalition of Remainer Tories, Labour, SNP and LIbDems to extend A50 and either agree a very soft Brexit and/or put options to a people's vote. The Queen would have to be assured that this grouping had the confidence of the House and the Speaker would have to facilitate it. It would be high drama.
    Well they are all remainers and civil war would break out in politics. It needs someone who can command respect from both sides and at present I do not see anyone though that could change
    It can only be Ken Clarke in that case. Watch how he has Farage eating out of his hand.

    https://twitter.com/Haggis_UK/status/1010100142215761921
    How pissed did Ken Clarke sound in that clip?
  • Options
    Big_G_NorthWalesBig_G_NorthWales Posts: 60,247

    Barnesian said:

    Barnesian said:

    Brexit will not be derailed by any legal stuff. That's pie in the sky.

    It could be derailed by a big switch in public opinion (which probably won't happen) that causes the PM and LOTO to reconsider their strategy.

    It could also be derailed by May procrastinating to the very end because of the contradictions in her position and threats from her cabinet. The process might simply run out of road and adults take over at the last moment in a constitutional crisis that will test the Queen and the Speaker.

    Interesting but who are your adults - genuine question
    Grieve, Hammond(P), Umanna, Starmer, Cable, Blackford.

    It would be a real crisis with the prospect of crashing out with no preparations and really dire consequences. It would be a national emergency - the scenario that keeps Grieve awake at night. There would be a vote of no confidence in the government with a temporary coalition of Remainer Tories, Labour, SNP and LIbDems to extend A50 and either agree a very soft Brexit and/or put options to a people's vote. The Queen would have to be assured that this grouping had the confidence of the House and the Speaker would have to facilitate it. It would be high drama.
    Well they are all remainers and civil war would break out in politics. It needs someone who can command respect from both sides and at present I do not see anyone though that could change
    It can only be Ken Clarke in that case. Watch how he has Farage eating out of his hand.

    https://twitter.com/Haggis_UK/status/1010100142215761921
    You really do not get it. It would have to be someone acceptable to both sides and Ken Clarke has no chance of that. You may as well appoint Juncker though you probably would
  • Options
    BarnesianBarnesian Posts: 7,987
    It is important to consider the endgame if May continues to procrastinate and not face up to the contradictions in her position and her opponents in Cabinet. There will be an endgame. It is inescapable.

    I think Grieve was rehearsing this in his tortured journey to a meaningful vote if there is no deal. He will have a key role with Starmer where there mutual respect (Starmer was DPP under Grieve as AG).
  • Options
    CarlottaVanceCarlottaVance Posts: 59,572
    rcs1000 said:

    Barnesian said:

    Brexit will not be derailed by any legal stuff. That's pie in the sky.

    It could be derailed by a big switch in public opinion (which probably won't happen) that causes the PM and LOTO to reconsider their strategy.

    It could also be derailed by May procrastinating to the very end because of the contradictions in her position and threats from her cabinet. The process might simply run out of road and adults take over at the last moment in a constitutional crisis that will test the Queen and the Speaker.

    Interesting but who are your adults - genuine question
    I think the plan is for Juncker to stand at the next by-election in the UK. When he is elected with 99% of the vote, he then leads a revolt by pro-EU MPs, and becomes Prime Minister.

    In his dual roles, he puts Britain at the heart of Europe, and introduces the Euro to the UK. He is hailed by all as the greatest statesman of his age.
    I prefer the scenario where the Queen Mother is revealed not to have died, is absolved of her involvement in the assassination of Princess Diana (they never did find that white Fiat), extolles her daughter to summon the Dunkirk spirit and put Britain on a wartime footing - after seeing both their food exports and food imports rot at Holyhead, Ireland sues the EU to settle on terms dictated by Prime Minister Gove, who sadly is shortly thereafter taken from us after an accident on an Aberdeen fishing boat. Prime Minister Javid then comes out as gay and the Labour Front Bench spontaneously combusts...
  • Options
    williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 48,011
    Barnesian said:

    It is important to consider the endgame if May continues to procrastinate and not face up to the contradictions in her position and her opponents in Cabinet. There will be an endgame. It is inescapable.

    It's important to bear in mind that May has a penchant for dramatised set piece interventions. There's a common thread running all the way from the nasty party speech through to the snap election. She will have plans for a game changer of her own, but we just don't know what it is yet.
  • Options
    Big_G_NorthWalesBig_G_NorthWales Posts: 60,247
    Barnesian said:

    It is important to consider the endgame if May continues to procrastinate and not face up to the contradictions in her position and her opponents in Cabinet. There will be an endgame. It is inescapable.

    I think Grieve was rehearsing this in his tortured journey to a meaningful vote if there is no deal. He will have a key role with Starmer where there mutual respect (Starmer was DPP under Grieve as AG).

    Both Remainers - would create fury - not going to happen

    Who knows what will happen but remainers and leavers need to realise they both have to compromise

    And hopefully TM will arrive at that compromise
  • Options
    Stark_DawningStark_Dawning Posts: 9,287

    As much as the Leavers would like some kind of legal challenge to derail Brexit this will not, and indeed should not, be allowed to happen. There must be no easy left off for those who orchestrated this mischief. We hear today that Farage is airily content to see British manufacturing put to the sword to facilitate his plans. I'd hate to see this happen myself, but 'the Will of the People' and all that. No, the Leavers have made their decision. Not seeing it through is the coward's way out.

    Are you sure you mean leavers in your first sentence
    Absolutely! They'd never admit it, but Leavers would secretly love Brexit to be cancelled, in a way in which they could still cry foul while breathing a silent sigh of relief.
  • Options
    williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 48,011

    Barnesian said:

    It is important to consider the endgame if May continues to procrastinate and not face up to the contradictions in her position and her opponents in Cabinet. There will be an endgame. It is inescapable.

    I think Grieve was rehearsing this in his tortured journey to a meaningful vote if there is no deal. He will have a key role with Starmer where there mutual respect (Starmer was DPP under Grieve as AG).

    Both Remainers - would create fury - not going to happen

    Who knows what will happen but remainers and leavers need to realise they both have to compromise

    And hopefully TM will arrive at that compromise
    Remainers can compromise by giving up on Dave's Deal, and Leavers can compromise by giving up on Brexit. That way nobody gets what they were campaigning for in the referendum.
  • Options
    Big_G_NorthWalesBig_G_NorthWales Posts: 60,247

    As much as the Leavers would like some kind of legal challenge to derail Brexit this will not, and indeed should not, be allowed to happen. There must be no easy left off for those who orchestrated this mischief. We hear today that Farage is airily content to see British manufacturing put to the sword to facilitate his plans. I'd hate to see this happen myself, but 'the Will of the People' and all that. No, the Leavers have made their decision. Not seeing it through is the coward's way out.

    Are you sure you mean leavers in your first sentence
    Absolutely! They'd never admit it, but Leavers would secretly love Brexit to be cancelled, in a way in which they could still cry foul while breathing a silent sigh of relief.
    Strange logic
  • Options
    AlastairMeeksAlastairMeeks Posts: 30,340

    Barnesian said:

    It is important to consider the endgame if May continues to procrastinate and not face up to the contradictions in her position and her opponents in Cabinet. There will be an endgame. It is inescapable.

    I think Grieve was rehearsing this in his tortured journey to a meaningful vote if there is no deal. He will have a key role with Starmer where there mutual respect (Starmer was DPP under Grieve as AG).

    Both Remainers - would create fury - not going to happen

    Who knows what will happen but remainers and leavers need to realise they both have to compromise

    And hopefully TM will arrive at that compromise
    I’m not expecting any compromise. I’m not expecting either side to be happy either. I expect continuing bitter conflict on the subject for the foreseeable future.
  • Options
    BarnesianBarnesian Posts: 7,987

    Barnesian said:

    Barnesian said:

    Brexit will not be derailed by any legal stuff. That's pie in the sky.

    It could be derailed by a big switch in public opinion (which probably won't happen) that causes the PM and LOTO to reconsider their strategy.

    It could also be derailed by May procrastinating to the very end because of the contradictions in her position and threats from her cabinet. The process might simply run out of road and adults take over at the last moment in a constitutional crisis that will test the Queen and the Speaker.

    Interesting but who are your adults - genuine question
    Grieve, Hammond(P), Umanna, Starmer, Cable, Blackford.

    It would be a real crisis with the prospect of crashing out with no preparations and really dire consequences. It would be a national emergency - the scenario that keeps Grieve awake at night. There would be a vote of no confidence in the government with a temporary coalition of Remainer Tories, Labour, SNP and LIbDems to extend A50 and either agree a very soft Brexit and/or put options to a people's vote. The Queen would have to be assured that this grouping had the confidence of the House and the Speaker would have to facilitate it. It would be high drama.
    Well they are all remainers and civil war would break out in politics. It needs someone who can command respect from both sides and at present I do not see anyone though that could change
    Mrs May was the candidate who could command respect from both sides and she has failed.

    There is already a civil war in parliament and in the cabinet. A civil war only ends when one side is the decisive winner. There is a majority for remain in parliament which is supreme (with help from the Queen and the Speaker) and that will determine the result.
  • Options
    CarlottaVanceCarlottaVance Posts: 59,572
    Meanwhile, in enlightened cosmopolitan Europe:

    https://twitter.com/nytimes/status/1010213353539690496?s=20
  • Options
    Big_G_NorthWalesBig_G_NorthWales Posts: 60,247
    Barnesian said:

    Barnesian said:

    Barnesian said:

    Brexit will not be derailed by any legal stuff. That's pie in the sky.

    It could be derailed by a big switch in public opinion (which probably won't happen) that causes the PM and LOTO to reconsider their strategy.

    It could also be derailed by May procrastinating to the very end because of the contradictions in her position and threats from her cabinet. The process might simply run out of road and adults take over at the last moment in a constitutional crisis that will test the Queen and the Speaker.

    Interesting but who are your adults - genuine question
    Grieve, Hammond(P), Umanna, Starmer, Cable, Blackford.

    It would be a real crisis with the prospect of crashing out with no preparations and really dire consequences. It would be a national emergency - the scenario that keeps Grieve awake at night. There would be a vote of no confidence in the government with a temporary coalition of Remainer Tories, Labour, SNP and LIbDems to extend A50 and either agree a very soft Brexit and/or put options to a people's vote. The Queen would have to be assured that this grouping had the confidence of the House and the Speaker would have to facilitate it. It would be high drama.
    Well they are all remainers and civil war would break out in politics. It needs someone who can command respect from both sides and at present I do not see anyone though that could change
    Mrs May was the candidate who could command respect from both sides and she has failed.

    There is already a civil war in parliament and in the cabinet. A civil war only ends when one side is the decisive winner. There is a majority for remain in parliament which is supreme (with help from the Queen and the Speaker) and that will determine the result.
    Desperate stuff when you have to suggest the Queen and the Speaker will conspire to keep us in the EU against a democratic vote of the people
  • Options
    williamglennwilliamglenn Posts: 48,011
  • Options
    welshowlwelshowl Posts: 4,460

    As much as the Leavers would like some kind of legal challenge to derail Brexit this will not, and indeed should not, be allowed to happen. There must be no easy left off for those who orchestrated this mischief. We hear today that Farage is airily content to see British manufacturing put to the sword to facilitate his plans. I'd hate to see this happen myself, but 'the Will of the People' and all that. No, the Leavers have made their decision. Not seeing it through is the coward's way out.

    Are you sure you mean leavers in your first sentence
    Absolutely! They'd never admit it, but Leavers would secretly love Brexit to be cancelled, in a way in which they could still cry foul while breathing a silent sigh of relief.
    Are you feeling ok? Otherwise what utter rot.
  • Options
    BarnesianBarnesian Posts: 7,987

    Barnesian said:

    It is important to consider the endgame if May continues to procrastinate and not face up to the contradictions in her position and her opponents in Cabinet. There will be an endgame. It is inescapable.

    It's important to bear in mind that May has a penchant for dramatised set piece interventions. There's a common thread running all the way from the nasty party speech through to the snap election. She will have plans for a game changer of her own, but we just don't know what it is yet.
    Good observation. I hope you are right.
  • Options
    OmniumOmnium Posts: 9,748

    As much as the Leavers would like some kind of legal challenge to derail Brexit this will not, and indeed should not, be allowed to happen. There must be no easy left off for those who orchestrated this mischief. We hear today that Farage is airily content to see British manufacturing put to the sword to facilitate his plans. I'd hate to see this happen myself, but 'the Will of the People' and all that. No, the Leavers have made their decision. Not seeing it through is the coward's way out.

    Are you sure you mean leavers in your first sentence
    Absolutely! They'd never admit it, but Leavers would secretly love Brexit to be cancelled, in a way in which they could still cry foul while breathing a silent sigh of relief.
    I think I'd prefer to leave and then reapply. At least we have some semblance of a constitution if we do that. Something must be done, and be seen to have been done as a result of the referendum.

    I think we're far enough along with the process that its just a matter of getting to actual Brexit. After that everything can be finessed at everyone's leisure. We could rejoin the most euro-hugger of things on a case-by-case basis. The default position is the only thing that's changed - our new default is don't join, whereas our old default was join, and in fact must join.
  • Options
    CarlottaVanceCarlottaVance Posts: 59,572

    As much as the Leavers would like some kind of legal challenge to derail Brexit this will not, and indeed should not, be allowed to happen. There must be no easy left off for those who orchestrated this mischief. We hear today that Farage is airily content to see British manufacturing put to the sword to facilitate his plans. I'd hate to see this happen myself, but 'the Will of the People' and all that. No, the Leavers have made their decision. Not seeing it through is the coward's way out.

    Are you sure you mean leavers in your first sentence
    Absolutely! They'd never admit it, but Leavers would secretly love Brexit to be cancelled, in a way in which they could still cry foul while breathing a silent sigh of relief.
    Bartender! I’ll have one of what he’s having - but make mine a single...
  • Options
    BarnesianBarnesian Posts: 7,987

    Barnesian said:

    Barnesian said:

    Barnesian said:

    Brexit will not be derailed by any legal stuff. That's pie in the sky.

    It could be derailed by a big switch in public opinion (which probably won't happen) that causes the PM and LOTO to reconsider their strategy.

    It could also be derailed by May procrastinating to the very end because of the contradictions in her position and threats from her cabinet. The process might simply run out of road and adults take over at the last moment in a constitutional crisis that will test the Queen and the Speaker.

    Interesting but who are your adults - genuine question
    Grieve, Hammond(P), Umanna, Starmer, Cable, Blackford.

    It would be a real crisis with the prospect of crashing out with no preparations and really dire consequences. It would be a national emergency - the scenario that keeps Grieve awake at night. There would be a vote of no confidence in the government with a temporary coalition of Remainer Tories, Labour, SNP and LIbDems to extend A50 and either agree a very soft Brexit and/or put options to a people's vote. The Queen would have to be assured that this grouping had the confidence of the House and the Speaker would have to facilitate it. It would be high drama.
    Well they are all remainers and civil war would break out in politics. It needs someone who can command respect from both sides and at present I do not see anyone though that could change
    Mrs May was the candidate who could command respect from both sides and she has failed.

    There is already a civil war in parliament and in the cabinet. A civil war only ends when one side is the decisive winner. There is a majority for remain in parliament which is supreme (with help from the Queen and the Speaker) and that will determine the result.
    Desperate stuff when you have to suggest the Queen and the Speaker will conspire to keep us in the EU against a democratic vote of the people
    Desperate times if we are faced with an unprepared crash-out. It would be a very serious national emergency.
  • Options
    BarnesianBarnesian Posts: 7,987

    rcs1000 said:

    Barnesian said:

    Brexit will not be derailed by any legal stuff. That's pie in the sky.

    It could be derailed by a big switch in public opinion (which probably won't happen) that causes the PM and LOTO to reconsider their strategy.

    It could also be derailed by May procrastinating to the very end because of the contradictions in her position and threats from her cabinet. The process might simply run out of road and adults take over at the last moment in a constitutional crisis that will test the Queen and the Speaker.

    Interesting but who are your adults - genuine question
    I think the plan is for Juncker to stand at the next by-election in the UK. When he is elected with 99% of the vote, he then leads a revolt by pro-EU MPs, and becomes Prime Minister.

    In his dual roles, he puts Britain at the heart of Europe, and introduces the Euro to the UK. He is hailed by all as the greatest statesman of his age.
    I prefer the scenario where the Queen Mother is revealed not to have died, is absolved of her involvement in the assassination of Princess Diana (they never did find that white Fiat), extolles her daughter to summon the Dunkirk spirit and put Britain on a wartime footing - after seeing both their food exports and food imports rot at Holyhead, Ireland sues the EU to settle on terms dictated by Prime Minister Gove, who sadly is shortly thereafter taken from us after an accident on an Aberdeen fishing boat. Prime Minister Javid then comes out as gay and the Labour Front Bench spontaneously combusts...
    Now now children. This is serious.
  • Options
    CarlottaVanceCarlottaVance Posts: 59,572

    Barnesian said:

    It is important to consider the endgame if May continues to procrastinate and not face up to the contradictions in her position and her opponents in Cabinet. There will be an endgame. It is inescapable.

    It's important to bear in mind that May has a penchant for dramatised set piece interventions. There's a common thread running all the way from the nasty party speech through to the snap election. She will have plans for a game changer of her own, but we just don't know what it is yet.
    Mrs May’s “game changers” have had, at best, “mixed” results....
  • Options
    PulpstarPulpstar Posts: 75,900
    Omnium said:

    As much as the Leavers would like some kind of legal challenge to derail Brexit this will not, and indeed should not, be allowed to happen. There must be no easy left off for those who orchestrated this mischief. We hear today that Farage is airily content to see British manufacturing put to the sword to facilitate his plans. I'd hate to see this happen myself, but 'the Will of the People' and all that. No, the Leavers have made their decision. Not seeing it through is the coward's way out.

    Are you sure you mean leavers in your first sentence
    Absolutely! They'd never admit it, but Leavers would secretly love Brexit to be cancelled, in a way in which they could still cry foul while breathing a silent sigh of relief.
    I think I'd prefer to leave and then reapply. At least we have some semblance of a constitution if we do that. Something must be done, and be seen to have been done as a result of the referendum.

    I think we're far enough along with the process that its just a matter of getting to actual Brexit. After that everything can be finessed at everyone's leisure. We could rejoin the most euro-hugger of things on a case-by-case basis. The default position is the only thing that's changed - our new default is don't join, whereas our old default was join, and in fact must join.
    Leaving then rejoining would honour the referendum result whereas remaining would not. Like Ireland's abortion laws the consent would be with the British people
  • Options
    FoxyFoxy Posts: 44,517

    Meanwhile, in enlightened cosmopolitan Europe:

    https://twitter.com/nytimes/status/1010213353539690496?s=20

    Yes, Kippers should be quite happy there....
  • Options
    BarnesianBarnesian Posts: 7,987
    Pulpstar said:

    Omnium said:

    As much as the Leavers would like some kind of legal challenge to derail Brexit this will not, and indeed should not, be allowed to happen. There must be no easy left off for those who orchestrated this mischief. We hear today that Farage is airily content to see British manufacturing put to the sword to facilitate his plans. I'd hate to see this happen myself, but 'the Will of the People' and all that. No, the Leavers have made their decision. Not seeing it through is the coward's way out.

    Are you sure you mean leavers in your first sentence
    Absolutely! They'd never admit it, but Leavers would secretly love Brexit to be cancelled, in a way in which they could still cry foul while breathing a silent sigh of relief.
    I think I'd prefer to leave and then reapply. At least we have some semblance of a constitution if we do that. Something must be done, and be seen to have been done as a result of the referendum.

    I think we're far enough along with the process that its just a matter of getting to actual Brexit. After that everything can be finessed at everyone's leisure. We could rejoin the most euro-hugger of things on a case-by-case basis. The default position is the only thing that's changed - our new default is don't join, whereas our old default was join, and in fact must join.
    Leaving then rejoining would honour the referendum result whereas remaining would not. Like Ireland's abortion laws the consent would be with the British people
    Leaving with an unprepared crashout might honour the referendum result but would be completely insane. It would be parliament's duty to prevent that.
  • Options
    ydoethurydoethur Posts: 67,109

    As much as the Leavers would like some kind of legal challenge to derail Brexit this will not, and indeed should not, be allowed to happen. There must be no easy left off for those who orchestrated this mischief. We hear today that Farage is airily content to see British manufacturing put to the sword to facilitate his plans. I'd hate to see this happen myself, but 'the Will of the People' and all that. No, the Leavers have made their decision. Not seeing it through is the coward's way out.

    Are you sure you mean leavers in your first sentence
    Absolutely! They'd never admit it, but Leavers would secretly love Brexit to be cancelled, in a way in which they could still cry foul while breathing a silent sigh of relief.
    Bartender! I’ll have one of what he’s having - but make mine a single...
    I think looking at the posts tonight everyone seems to have been drinking either pints of Junker's favourite tipple, or an especially strong pan-Galactic Gargle Blaster.

    Either that or SeanT has hacked everyone's account and is amusing himself by playing out every different scenario at once.
  • Options
    ydoethurydoethur Posts: 67,109

    Barnesian said:

    It is important to consider the endgame if May continues to procrastinate and not face up to the contradictions in her position and her opponents in Cabinet. There will be an endgame. It is inescapable.

    It's important to bear in mind that May has a penchant for dramatised set piece interventions. There's a common thread running all the way from the nasty party speech through to the snap election. She will have plans for a game changer of her own, but we just don't know what it is yet.
    Mrs May’s “game changers” have had, at best, “mixed” results....
    Have they? Which one was mixed?

    The ones I remember were all disasters.
  • Options
    FoxyFoxy Posts: 44,517

    As much as the Leavers would like some kind of legal challenge to derail Brexit this will not, and indeed should not, be allowed to happen. There must be no easy left off for those who orchestrated this mischief. We hear today that Farage is airily content to see British manufacturing put to the sword to facilitate his plans. I'd hate to see this happen myself, but 'the Will of the People' and all that. No, the Leavers have made their decision. Not seeing it through is the coward's way out.

    An interesting quote on the Will of the People, from the FT, any guesses as to the speaker? :

    “The will of the People is the will of the Government and vice versa. The modern structure of the state is a higher form of democracy in which, by virtue of the people’s mandate, government is exercised authoritatively where there is no possibility of parliamentary interference, to obliterate and render ineffective the execution of the nation’s will. “
  • Options
    ydoethurydoethur Posts: 67,109
    Foxy said:

    As much as the Leavers would like some kind of legal challenge to derail Brexit this will not, and indeed should not, be allowed to happen. There must be no easy left off for those who orchestrated this mischief. We hear today that Farage is airily content to see British manufacturing put to the sword to facilitate his plans. I'd hate to see this happen myself, but 'the Will of the People' and all that. No, the Leavers have made their decision. Not seeing it through is the coward's way out.

    An interesting quote on the Will of the People, from the FT, any guesses as to the speaker? :

    “The will of the People is the will of the Government and vice versa. The modern structure of the state is a higher form of democracy in which, by virtue of the people’s mandate, government is exercised authoritatively where there is no possibility of parliamentary interference, to obliterate and render ineffective the execution of the nation’s will. “
    Will of the People - that must be the Duke of Cambridge.

    I will get my coat because I have to go out. Have a good evening.
  • Options
    anothernickanothernick Posts: 3,578
    edited June 2018

    Barnesian said:

    It is important to consider the endgame if May continues to procrastinate and not face up to the contradictions in her position and her opponents in Cabinet. There will be an endgame. It is inescapable.

    It's important to bear in mind that May has a penchant for dramatised set piece interventions. There's a common thread running all the way from the nasty party speech through to the snap election. She will have plans for a game changer of her own, but we just don't know what it is yet.
    Frankly if May was going to salvage something from this mess she would have done it by now. No one trusts her, not even her own cabinet, and her leadership and communication skills are virtually non existent. If she announced tomorrow that she favoured some form of soft Brexit people would doubt her veracity and interpret it as a mealy-mouthed attempt to win over some faction or other for a parliamentary vote next week. In any case, the divisions in the Tory Party are too deep and animosities too bitter for them to be bridged by a single intervention by anyone.
  • Options
    FoxyFoxy Posts: 44,517

    My favourite market of the last year.

    For what it's worth I'd have thought there's no better than a 1 in 6 chance of the date being put back, and probably much lower than that.

    I reckon an A50 extension is a definite possibility, so have banked my profit on this market.

    I suspect that May will eat humble pie and sign up to the EU27 Deal in the end. She doesnt want tobe at the wheel when the crash happens.
  • Options
    FF43FF43 Posts: 15,692
    edited June 2018
    Barnesian said:

    It is important to consider the endgame if May continues to procrastinate and not face up to the contradictions in her position and her opponents in Cabinet. There will be an endgame. It is inescapable.

    I think Grieve was rehearsing this in his tortured journey to a meaningful vote if there is no deal. He will have a key role with Starmer where there mutual respect (Starmer was DPP under Grieve as AG).

    Correct. There needs to be a crisis so the necessary resolution happens. At that point people will stop caring about immigration, payments to Brussels etc. It could be extremely painful. Right now everyone is in denial. In particular the Government. Leavers are obviously in denial, but Remainers too, to some extent.
  • Options
    Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 55,267
    Did you even read the post on the previous thread?

    https://www2.deloitte.com/content/dam/Deloitte/de/Documents/Brexit/Brexit-Briefings_Pt5_Hard-Brexit-German-car-industry.pdf

    The German carmarkers are in far deeper shit than we'd be (we'd actually be slightly better off) in the event of a no-deal Brexit.

    These are political manoeveres. Plain and simple.
  • Options
    Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 55,267

    Barnesian said:

    It is important to consider the endgame if May continues to procrastinate and not face up to the contradictions in her position and her opponents in Cabinet. There will be an endgame. It is inescapable.

    I think Grieve was rehearsing this in his tortured journey to a meaningful vote if there is no deal. He will have a key role with Starmer where there mutual respect (Starmer was DPP under Grieve as AG).

    Both Remainers - would create fury - not going to happen

    Who knows what will happen but remainers and leavers need to realise they both have to compromise

    And hopefully TM will arrive at that compromise
    I’m not expecting any compromise. I’m not expecting either side to be happy either. I expect continuing bitter conflict on the subject for the foreseeable future.
    I'm not sure I can be arsed.

    Life's too short.
  • Options
    Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 55,267
    rcs1000 said:

    Barnesian said:

    Brexit will not be derailed by any legal stuff. That's pie in the sky.

    It could be derailed by a big switch in public opinion (which probably won't happen) that causes the PM and LOTO to reconsider their strategy.

    It could also be derailed by May procrastinating to the very end because of the contradictions in her position and threats from her cabinet. The process might simply run out of road and adults take over at the last moment in a constitutional crisis that will test the Queen and the Speaker.

    Interesting but who are your adults - genuine question
    I think the plan is for Juncker to stand at the next by-election in the UK. When he is elected with 99% of the vote, he then leads a revolt by pro-EU MPs, and becomes Prime Minister.

    In his dual roles, he puts Britain at the heart of Europe, and introduces the Euro to the UK. He is hailed by all as the greatest statesman of his age.
    I think William Glenn is going to have some private "quiet time" with this post later this evening.
  • Options
    tlg86tlg86 Posts: 25,187
    Serbia 1-0 Kosovo.
  • Options
    Philip_ThompsonPhilip_Thompson Posts: 65,826
    tlg86 said:

    Serbia 1-0 Kosovo.

    Kosovo?
  • Options
    Sean_FSean_F Posts: 35,789
    Foxy said:

    As much as the Leavers would like some kind of legal challenge to derail Brexit this will not, and indeed should not, be allowed to happen. There must be no easy left off for those who orchestrated this mischief. We hear today that Farage is airily content to see British manufacturing put to the sword to facilitate his plans. I'd hate to see this happen myself, but 'the Will of the People' and all that. No, the Leavers have made their decision. Not seeing it through is the coward's way out.

    An interesting quote on the Will of the People, from the FT, any guesses as to the speaker? :

    “The will of the People is the will of the Government and vice versa. The modern structure of the state is a higher form of democracy in which, by virtue of the people’s mandate, government is exercised authoritatively where there is no possibility of parliamentary interference, to obliterate and render ineffective the execution of the nation’s will. “
    Justin Trudeau?
  • Options
    another_richardanother_richard Posts: 25,046
    rcs1000 said:

    Barnesian said:

    Barnesian said:

    Brexit will not be derailed by any legal stuff. That's pie in the sky.

    It could be derailed by a big switch in public opinion (which probably won't happen) that causes the PM and LOTO to reconsider their strategy.

    It could also be derailed by May procrastinating to the very end because of the contradictions in her position and threats from her cabinet. The process might simply run out of road and adults take over at the last moment in a constitutional crisis that will test the Queen and the Speaker.

    Interesting but who are your adults - genuine question
    Grieve, Hammond(P), Umanna, Starmer, Cable, Blackford.

    It would be a real crisis with the prospect of crashing out with no preparations and really dire consequences. It would be a national emergency - the scenario that keeps Grieve awake at night. There would be a vote of no confidence in the government with a temporary coalition of Remainer Tories, Labour, SNP and LIbDems to extend A50 and either agree a very soft Brexit and/or put options to a people's vote. The Queen would have to be assured that this grouping had the confidence of the House and the Speaker would have to facilitate it. It would be high drama.
    Well they are all remainers and civil war would break out in politics. It needs someone who can command respect from both sides and at present I do not see anyone though that could change
    It can only be Ken Clarke in that case. Watch how he has Farage eating out of his hand.

    https://twitter.com/Haggis_UK/status/1010100142215761921
    How pissed did Ken Clarke sound in that clip?
    Didn't Ken Clarke say in his autobiography that he's consumed alcohol every day for over fifty years ?
  • Options
    tlg86tlg86 Posts: 25,187

    tlg86 said:

    Serbia 1-0 Kosovo.

    Kosovo?
    A number of the Swiss side are from Kosovo.
  • Options
    HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 116,938

    As much as the Leavers would like some kind of legal challenge to derail Brexit this will not, and indeed should not, be allowed to happen. There must be no easy left off for those who orchestrated this mischief. We hear today that Farage is airily content to see British manufacturing put to the sword to facilitate his plans. I'd hate to see this happen myself, but 'the Will of the People' and all that. No, the Leavers have made their decision. Not seeing it through is the coward's way out.

    Are you sure you mean leavers in your first sentence
    Absolutely! They'd never admit it, but Leavers would secretly love Brexit to be cancelled, in a way in which they could still cry foul while breathing a silent sigh of relief.
    Farage certainly would, UKIP would be on 30% in the polls within a week and Farage could 'reluctantly' re enter the fray as UKIP leader to represent 'the people' against the political elite
  • Options
    HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 116,938
    edited June 2018
    rcs1000 said:

    Barnesian said:

    Brexit will not be derailed by any legal stuff. That's pie in the sky.

    It could be derailed by a big switch in public opinion (which probably won't happen) that causes the PM and LOTO to reconsider their strategy.

    It could also be derailed by May procrastinating to the very end because of the contradictions in her position and threats from her cabinet. The process might simply run out of road and adults take over at the last moment in a constitutional crisis that will test the Queen and the Speaker.

    Interesting but who are your adults - genuine question
    I think the plan is for Juncker to stand at the next by-election in the UK. When he is elected with 99% of the vote, he then leads a revolt by pro-EU MPs, and becomes Prime Minister.

    In his dual roles, he puts Britain at the heart of Europe, and introduces the Euro to the UK. He is hailed by all as the greatest statesman of his age.
    Sounds as cunning a plan as John Steven's Pro Euro Conservative Party's plan to beat Hague's Tories at the 1999 European elections
  • Options
    dixiedeandixiedean Posts: 27,940
    Reckon Yugoslavia would have walked this tournament.
  • Options
    JosiasJessopJosiasJessop Posts: 38,889

    Did you even read the post on the previous thread?

    https://www2.deloitte.com/content/dam/Deloitte/de/Documents/Brexit/Brexit-Briefings_Pt5_Hard-Brexit-German-car-industry.pdf

    The German carmarkers are in far deeper shit than we'd be (we'd actually be slightly better off) in the event of a no-deal Brexit.

    These are political manoeveres. Plain and simple.
    Whilst there is some truth in your last line, I doubt it is as plain, simple or one-dimensional as that. People - and especially successful multinational companies - usually weigh up a whole load of factors when making decisions or statements.

    They generally don't just spout any old sh*te off the top of their heads based on headlines. We can leave that to politicians. ;)
  • Options
    Wulfrun_PhilWulfrun_Phil Posts: 4,597

    Did you even read the post on the previous thread?

    https://www2.deloitte.com/content/dam/Deloitte/de/Documents/Brexit/Brexit-Briefings_Pt5_Hard-Brexit-German-car-industry.pdf

    The German carmarkers are in far deeper shit than we'd be (we'd actually be slightly better off) in the event of a no-deal Brexit.

    These are political manoeveres. Plain and simple.
    Perhaps the UK Government should float the idea of a law to the effect that the flag of the main country of manufacture of every car built post Brexit should by law be displayed on the vehicle.
  • Options
    anothernickanothernick Posts: 3,578
    Foxy said:

    As much as the Leavers would like some kind of legal challenge to derail Brexit this will not, and indeed should not, be allowed to happen. There must be no easy left off for those who orchestrated this mischief. We hear today that Farage is airily content to see British manufacturing put to the sword to facilitate his plans. I'd hate to see this happen myself, but 'the Will of the People' and all that. No, the Leavers have made their decision. Not seeing it through is the coward's way out.

    An interesting quote on the Will of the People, from the FT, any guesses as to the speaker? :

    “The will of the People is the will of the Government and vice versa. The modern structure of the state is a higher form of democracy in which, by virtue of the people’s mandate, government is exercised authoritatively where there is no possibility of parliamentary interference, to obliterate and render ineffective the execution of the nation’s will. “
    Josef Goebbels. The Nazis considered themselves to be the embodiment of the will of the people since they created their dictatorship and the position of fuhrer through the use of referenda. Their most famous propaganda film was called Triumph of the Will. And of course they arraigned their political opponents in show trials conducted in Peoples' Courts (a name also used for the courts which conducted Stalin's show trials).

    Those who claim to be embodying the will of the people should be more aware of the uncomfortable history of this claim.
  • Options
    Casino_RoyaleCasino_Royale Posts: 55,267

    Did you even read the post on the previous thread?

    https://www2.deloitte.com/content/dam/Deloitte/de/Documents/Brexit/Brexit-Briefings_Pt5_Hard-Brexit-German-car-industry.pdf

    The German carmarkers are in far deeper shit than we'd be (we'd actually be slightly better off) in the event of a no-deal Brexit.

    These are political manoeveres. Plain and simple.
    Whilst there is some truth in your last line, I doubt it is as plain, simple or one-dimensional as that. People - and especially successful multinational companies - usually weigh up a whole load of factors when making decisions or statements.

    They generally don't just spout any old sh*te off the top of their heads based on headlines. We can leave that to politicians. ;)
    Of course, but the fact these announcements are all coming out on the same day, only days before the European Council meeting, is no coincidence.
  • Options
    rcs1000rcs1000 Posts: 53,920

    Did you even read the post on the previous thread?

    https://www2.deloitte.com/content/dam/Deloitte/de/Documents/Brexit/Brexit-Briefings_Pt5_Hard-Brexit-German-car-industry.pdf

    The German carmarkers are in far deeper shit than we'd be (we'd actually be slightly better off) in the event of a no-deal Brexit.

    These are political manoeveres. Plain and simple.
    Perhaps the UK Government should float the idea of a law to the effect that the flag of the main country of manufacture of every car built post Brexit should by law be displayed on the vehicle.
    If it's assembled in the UK of entirely French parts, is that a British car?
This discussion has been closed.