Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.

politicalbetting.com » Blog Archive » A Government of Laws

124678

Comments

  • dyedwooliedyedwoolie Posts: 7,786
    Boris bad week bounce
  • noneoftheabovenoneoftheabove Posts: 20,462
    edited September 2019
    AndyJS said:

    The Tories and Brexit Party ought to make a pact since they're on about 46% combined. But they probably won't since Cummings apparently can't stand Farage.

    They wont be on 46% combined if they merge though, some conservative voters cant stand Farage, and some Brexit voters are very anti Tory. Wont be surprised if it happens over the next few months though, there doesnt seem much point kicking out Hammond and his natural support unless you bring someone else in with new support.
  • GallowgateGallowgate Posts: 19,072
    “The Conservatives are up 3 points to 35% of the vote, while the Brexit party is down 3 points to 13%. The Liberal Democrats are up 2 points to 17% while Labour is down 1 point to 25%.”
  • nico67nico67 Posts: 4,502
    Panelbase is underwhelming for Bozo.

    The May polls were effected by the Euro elections and so the + 10 is really from a very low base .

    Doesn’t really show what’s really going on because the last poll is so far back . No doubt the Sunday Times will report it as a huge surge for Bozo !
  • malcolmgmalcolmg Posts: 41,684

    DougSeal said:

    Scott_P said:
    Yes Stewart you did. You betrayed your party and country and colluded with the enemy before doing so.
    Also I would love to know in what capacity you have served your country that allows you to so disgracefully demean a former armed serviceman and civil servant in that way.
    Robert E. Lee was an active armed serviceman. Didn't stop him betraying his country.
    now you are away with the birds , WTF has the American Civil War got to do with brexit and our archaic machinations in our outdated shitty parliament , apart from both had lots of donkeys involved.
  • OldKingColeOldKingCole Posts: 31,726

    SMITH OUT!

    Great news. Caught by Stokes off Leach.
  • Noo said:

    At least SLab are beating TBP in that Yougov SCon constituency only poll. They'll probably take that in the current climate.

    https://twitter.com/BallotBoxScot/status/1170086850700161025?s=20

    SLab down 10 is entirely consistent with recent results in by elections.

    Ian Murray stands alone on the barricades of Morningside.
    Murray, like Swinson, is entirely dependent on mass SCon tactical voting. In the current harsh split within Unionism, I cannot see that pattern holding.
    Morningside is safe territory for Murray. It's Remain central, Murray is well known and liked as a constituency MP, and they know him to be hostile to the excesses of Corbynism. Any rotting of Labour from the head down will reach Morningside last of all. There will not be a change of MP unless Murray stands down or the boundaries change.
    I didn’t say Murray would lose. I said that I cannot see the 2017 pattern of mass SCon tactical voting holding, due to the current harsh split within Unionism.*

    Murray ought to hold on in Edinburgh South, on a much reduced majority. As should Christine Jardine in Edinburgh West.

    But Jo Swinson and Jamie Stone are *much* more vulnerable to Unionist unwind. Swinson’s new profile as party leader ought to help her, but Caithness, Sutherland and Easter Ross is anyone’s guess. Depends a lot on the calibre of the SNP candidate. Weirdly, the Brexit Party have already selected a PPC for that seat (Sandra Skinner).

    (* For the avoidance of doubt, the current harsh split within Unionism = Brexit)
  • malcolmg said:

    DougSeal said:

    Scott_P said:
    Yes Stewart you did. You betrayed your party and country and colluded with the enemy before doing so.
    Also I would love to know in what capacity you have served your country that allows you to so disgracefully demean a former armed serviceman and civil servant in that way.
    Robert E. Lee was an active armed serviceman. Didn't stop him betraying his country.
    now you are away with the birds , WTF has the American Civil War got to do with brexit and our archaic machinations in our outdated shitty parliament , apart from both had lots of donkeys involved.
    It was a dismissal of the appeal to authority fallacy that was made by saying Stewart was a serviceman.

    If the SNP won a Yes referendum then during negotiations SNP MSPs in Holyrood were colluding with English MPs to obstruct Scottish independence and keep Scotland in the UK then that would be comparable.
  • GallowgateGallowgate Posts: 19,072
    Still no trace of this Con 40%+ that was predicted.
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 116,719
    edited September 2019

    “The Conservatives are up 3 points to 35% of the vote, while the Brexit party is down 3 points to 13%. The Liberal Democrats are up 2 points to 17% while Labour is down 1 point to 25%.”

    Electoral Calculus gives a Tory landslide and a Tory majority of 104 with this evening's Opinium.

    Tories 377
    Labour 184
    LDs 32

    Biggest Tory win since Thatcher for Boris if true

    https://www.electoralcalculus.co.uk/cgi-bin/usercode.py?CON=35&LAB=25&LIB=17&Brexit=14&Green=3&UKIP=1&TVCON=&TVLAB=&TVLIB=&TVBrexit=&TVGreen=&TVUKIP=&SCOTCON=&SCOTLAB=&SCOTLIB=&SCOTBrexit=&SCOTGreen=&SCOTUKIP=&SCOTNAT=&display=AllChanged&regorseat=(none)&boundary=2017base
  • AndyJSAndyJS Posts: 29,395

    10% Tory lead in Opinium

    Do we have the figures?
  • malcolmg said:

    RobD said:

    GIN1138 said:

    RobD said:

    Refusing royal assent would be outrageous. The Parliament has passed a law, you can't just ignore it because it is inconvenient.

    It would be... But we've long gone past the point where Parliamentary conventions actually count for anything.
    I dunno about you, but I quite like conventions, it's part of what being a Tory is all about.
    It is all bollox so they can control the plebs, rotten to the core.
    It's all because we've had 300 years or more to write down our constitution and have never bothered to get around to it. Too lazy, or arrogant.

    Other countries that seem to get by on unwritten constitutions, aka random reports and writings include NZ and Israel ... but they've not had centuries to write it all down in one place.

    Hennessey said on R4 that the PM's action in proroguing so long was probably legal but it was very bad form not to follow convention. In other words, our constitution is so weak and pathetic that it falls apart if people at the top don't behave like gentlemen (or ladies.)
  • Still no trace of this Con 40%+ that was predicted.

    I predicted by the end of October, especially post-Tory Conference, if we went into prorogation with this law and without an election.
  • TGOHFTGOHF Posts: 21,633

    10% Tory lead in Opinium

    Corbyns cowardly chicken run looks justified now - how long can he cower for ? Until the spring ?
  • OldKingColeOldKingCole Posts: 31,726

    SMITH OUT!

    Great news. Caught by Stokes off Leach.
    Damn near another No Ball, too. How does a bowler like Leach bowl no-balls? Poor coaching IMHO!
  • GallowgateGallowgate Posts: 19,072
    AndyJS said:

    10% Tory lead in Opinium

    Do we have the figures?
    Con 35%
    Lab 25%
    LDem 17%
    Brexit 13%
  • HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    Given the current Parliament clearly has no interest in respecting the victorious Leave vote of 2016 I can certainly understand Boris in his determination to stand his ground and refuse to extend even if defying an Act of Parliament to do so.

    However assuming the anti No Deal Bill gets Royal Assent next week rather than disobey the law Boris should shift course to try and get the EU to agree a technical solution for the Irish border as an alternative to the backstop in the EU Council of October 17th and then get an amended Withdrawal Agreement through the Commons (which the Brady amendment suggested it would).


    If the EU does not agree to remove the backstop from the Withdrawal Agreement then Boris should resign as PM by October 31st and take the Tories into opposition on a No Deal platform until the backstop is removed and let the Commons elect someone else as PM to extend. If they have not done so by the 31st as Lord Sumption, a Supreme Court judge said today a civil servant can sign the extension on behalf of the Government instead

    How’s that going to work when the bill says that the extension must be requested by the 19th October unless Parliament votes for no deal or a new Brexit deal?
    The Commons could vote for the Withdrawal Agreement minus the backstop
    a day or two before and Boris can tell the EU to either take it and his technical solution for the Irish border or leave it
    No he can’t because “leave it” has been made illegal. The EU will quite rightly simply ignore him.
    If the EU ignores a Commons majority for the Withdrawal Agreement minus the backstop then Boris rightly goes into Opposition on a No Deal platform until they change their mind
    Why would Johnson in Opposition be of any interest to the EU whatsoever?
  • nico67nico67 Posts: 4,502
    Even less chance of Labour supporting an early election after the Opinium .

    They realize they only have s chance by splitting the Leave vote and must force the extension .
  • ByronicByronic Posts: 3,578
    IANAL but it looks to me like the Rebel Alliance have committed treason felony, according to the Act of 1848, which makes it a crime to “wage war against the sovereign” - by word, deed or act - “in order to put any force or constraint upon or in order to intimidate or overawe both Houses or either House of Parliament.”

    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treason_Felony_Act_1848

    If we’re going to lock up the Prime Minister on the basis of a strange new law thrown together last week, then we definitely need to jail the Rebel Alliance on the basis of a fundamental law, which has been in force since the mid 19th century.
  • The Conservatives are up 3 points to 35% of the vote, while the Brexit party is down 3 points to 13%. The Liberal Democrats are up 2 points to 17% while Labour is down 1 point to 25%.

    https://amp.theguardian.com/politics/2019/sep/07/tories-extend-lead-over-labour-to-10-despite-chaotic-week?utm_source=dlvr.it&utm_medium=twitter&__twitter_impression=true
  • GallowgateGallowgate Posts: 19,072
    Based on that 35% figure though, a significant amount of Tory Remainers must be switching too.

    This election will be very hard to predict.
  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 47,098
    Have the polls from the different pollsters ever been more all over the place?
  • TGOHFTGOHF Posts: 21,633
    nico67 said:

    Even less chance of Labour supporting an early election after the Opinium .

    They realize they only have s chance by splitting the Leave vote and must force the extension .

    Then what ? Keep the public enthused about more Brexit ?
  • GIN1138GIN1138 Posts: 20,697

    Still no trace of this Con 40%+ that was predicted.

    Did anyone say 40% immediatly?

    However if Jezza continues to deny people having a general election we may get to that.
  • Andrew said:

    HYUFD said:

    The Commons could vote for the Withdrawal Agreement minus the backstop
    a day or two before and Boris can tell the EU to either take it and his technical solution for the Irish border or leave it

    Even if Johnson was so inclined to bring it back, it wouldn't pass now.
    I do find this somewhat amusing. The no deal act mandated the 'Kinnock' amendment is brought back. It is being supported by Stephen Kinnock and Rory Stewart and is TM WDA with adjustments agreed between labour and TM prior to her resignation

    It has a considerable number of cross party supporters including Norman Lamb as far as I am aware
  • SMITH OUT!

    Great news. Caught by Stokes off Leach.
    Damn near another No Ball, too. How does a bowler like Leach bowl no-balls? Poor coaching IMHO!
    Apparently its a higher risk with slower balls.

    In order to surprise the batsman with a slower ball the spin bowler takes longer to release the ball and the foot naturally steps further forwards.

    OUT!
  • WhisperingOracleWhisperingOracle Posts: 8,480
    edited September 2019
    Any other pollsters due tonight, or later over the weekend ?
  • HYUFD said:

    “The Conservatives are up 3 points to 35% of the vote, while the Brexit party is down 3 points to 13%. The Liberal Democrats are up 2 points to 17% while Labour is down 1 point to 25%.”

    Electoral Calculus gives a Tory landslide and a Tory majority of 104 with this evening's Opinium.

    Tories 377
    Labour 184
    LDs 32

    Biggest Tory win since Thatcher for Boris if true

    https://www.electoralcalculus.co.uk/cgi-bin/usercode.py?CON=35&LAB=25&LIB=17&Brexit=14&Green=3&UKIP=1&TVCON=&TVLAB=&TVLIB=&TVBrexit=&TVGreen=&TVUKIP=&SCOTCON=&SCOTLAB=&SCOTLIB=&SCOTBrexit=&SCOTGreen=&SCOTUKIP=&SCOTNAT=&display=AllChanged&regorseat=(none)&boundary=2017base

    Tory gains in Scotland at the SNP’s expense again!!!

  • The Conservatives are up 3 points to 35% of the vote, while the Brexit party is down 3 points to 13%. The Liberal Democrats are up 2 points to 17% while Labour is down 1 point to 25%.

    https://amp.theguardian.com/politics/2019/sep/07/tories-extend-lead-over-labour-to-10-despite-chaotic-week?utm_source=dlvr.it&utm_medium=twitter&__twitter_impression=true

    Johnson’s personal ratings have been dented after his bruising week in the Commons. Now only just over a third (36%) think he would be the best prime minister, down from 41% last month. However, Jeremy Corbyn is not benefiting from Johnson’s troubles. Only 16% say he would be the best prime minister.

    Only 37% approve of the way that Johnson is handling the Brexit process, while 43% disapprove. However, that is better than than the ratings for Corbyn. Only 17% approve of the Labour leader’s response and 20% approve of Jo Swinson’s response.
    Johnson’s decision to prorogue parliament has not upset leave voters. The public as a whole is divided on this: 33% support the prime minister’s prorogation of parliament, while 36% oppose it. This is split evenly along EU referendum lines: 59% of leavers support the prorogation, while 61% of remainers oppose it.
  • GallowgateGallowgate Posts: 19,072
    GIN1138 said:

    Still no trace of this Con 40%+ that was predicted.

    Did anyone say 40% immediatly?

    However if Jezza continues to deny people having a general election we may get to that.

  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 116,719
    Streeter said:

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    Given the current Parliament clearly has no interest in respecting the victorious Leave vote of 2016 I can certainly understand Boris in his determination to stand his ground and refuse to extend even if defying an Act of Parliament to do so.

    However assuming the anti No Deal Bill gets Royal Assent next week rather than disobey the law Boris should shift course to try and get the EU to agree a technical solution for the Irish border as an alternative to the backstop in the EU Council of October 17th and then get an amended Withdrawal Agreement through the Commons (which the Brady amendment suggested it would).


    If the EU does not agree to remove the backstop from the Withdrawal Agreement then Boris should resign as PM by October 31st and take the Tories into opposition on a No Deal platform until the backstop is removed and let the Commons elect someone else as PM to extend. If they have not done so by the 31st as Lord Sumption, a Supreme Court judge said today a civil servant can sign the extension on behalf of the Government instead

    How’s that going to work when the bill says that the extension must be requested by the 19th October unless Parliament votes for no deal or a new Brexit deal?
    The Commons could vote for the Withdrawal Agreement minus the backstop
    a day or two before and Boris can tell the EU to either take it and his technical solution for the Irish border or leave it
    No he can’t because “leave it” has been made illegal. The EU will quite rightly simply ignore him.
    If the EU ignores a Commons majority for the Withdrawal Agreement minus the backstop then Boris rightly goes into Opposition on a No Deal platform until they change their mind
    Why would Johnson in Opposition be of any interest to the EU whatsoever?
    He wouldn't but he likely wins a majority at the next general election when he would be again
  • RobDRobD Posts: 58,941
    GIN1138 said:

    Changes with May.

    Only a 3 point lead over Labour. Oosh.

    https://twitter.com/britainelects/status/1170373770487500800?s=21

    Con +10 :open_mouth:
    Smelling salts on standby. :o

    Or a bounce back from 21% :p
  • Byronic said:

    IANAL but it looks to me like the Rebel Alliance have committed treason felony, according to the Act of 1848, which makes it a crime to “wage war against the sovereign” - by word, deed or act - “in order to put any force or constraint upon or in order to intimidate or overawe both Houses or either House of Parliament.”

    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treason_Felony_Act_1848

    If we’re going to lock up the Prime Minister on the basis of a strange new law thrown together last week, then we definitely need to jail the Rebel Alliance on the basis of a fundamental law, which has been in force since the mid 19th century.

    You started well, YANAL.
  • AndyJS said:

    10% Tory lead in Opinium

    Do we have the figures?
    Con 35%
    Lab 25%
    LDem 17%
    Brexit 13%
    Very easy to see 5% being squeezed from BXP to CON to get to 40% I'm predicting by end of October.
  • GIN1138GIN1138 Posts: 20,697
    nico67 said:

    Even less chance of Labour supporting an early election after the Opinium .

    They realize they only have s chance by splitting the Leave vote and must force the extension .

    I'm afraid the longer Labour continues to deny people a general election the worse their position will get before OR after Brexit is delayed.
  • malcolmgmalcolmg Posts: 41,684

    Fenman said:

    Scott_P said:
    Yes, Rory's right. They're starting to sound scary.
    Tbf if there were secret talks between the EU and the rebels and action agreed to subvert the UK government's position then it is collusion with a foreign power. The government are the only people that can negotiate with the EU.
    The language is of course deliberately provocative and not necessary
    Weren't they just checking that the EU would indeed grant an extension if one was requested? If anything they were being helpful to Boris - no point losing him his majority if No Deal was nailed on anyway. Boris and Cummings should be thanking them for injecting a bit of clarity and thoroughness.
    The EU is not a foreign power. We are members.
    The EU is a foreign power for these purposes, the EU's constitution makes this clear. We are not a part of the 27.
    We’re all citizens of that ‘foreign power’.
    Not by choice. Many of us consider their position little different to that of an occupying power.
    Not sure what relevance that has.
    It shows they have gone mental, and are living in la la land
  • GIN1138GIN1138 Posts: 20,697
    edited September 2019

    GIN1138 said:

    Still no trace of this Con 40%+ that was predicted.

    Did anyone say 40% immediatly?

    However if Jezza continues to deny people having a general election we may get to that.

    OK I may have had a rush of blood to the head.

    Still one can see the direction of travel. :D
  • malcolmgmalcolmg Posts: 41,684
    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    If other weekend polls are similar to the Panelbase and Survation ones, Johnson is in deep, deep trouble. Big if, though.

    No he isn't, Tories plus DUP have a majority with Survation and even with Panelbase the Tories would still comfortably be largest party.

    However both pollsters tend to have higher Labour voteshare and lower LD voteshares than Yougov or Ipsos Mori for example

    https://twitter.com/Adam_IoM/status/1170374866056417280?s=20

    One net gain for the SNP strongly suggests Electoral Calculus is predicting Tory gains in Scotland. Hmmm.

    It also ignores the Labour losses in Scotland to the SNP too though
    and the even bigger Tory losses to SNP as well
  • dyedwooliedyedwoolie Posts: 7,786
    malcolmg said:

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    If other weekend polls are similar to the Panelbase and Survation ones, Johnson is in deep, deep trouble. Big if, though.

    No he isn't, Tories plus DUP have a majority with Survation and even with Panelbase the Tories would still comfortably be largest party.

    However both pollsters tend to have higher Labour voteshare and lower LD voteshares than Yougov or Ipsos Mori for example

    https://twitter.com/Adam_IoM/status/1170374866056417280?s=20

    One net gain for the SNP strongly suggests Electoral Calculus is predicting Tory gains in Scotland. Hmmm.

    It also ignores the Labour losses in Scotland to the SNP too though
    and the even bigger Tory losses to SNP as well
    I agree with you malcolm, i cant see more than 3 to 5 Tory holds
  • nico67nico67 Posts: 4,502
    GIN1138 said:

    nico67 said:

    Even less chance of Labour supporting an early election after the Opinium .

    They realize they only have s chance by splitting the Leave vote and must force the extension .

    I'm afraid the longer Labour continues to deny people a general election the worse their position will get before OR after Brexit is delayed.
    Once in an election I doubt voters are going to be obsessed over a few weeks delay .
  • Any other pollsters due tonight, or later over the weekend ?

    There’s bound to be a YouGov.

  • HYUFD said:

    Streeter said:

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    Given the current Parliament clearly has no interest in respecting the victorious Leave vote of 2016 I can certainly understand Boris in his determination to stand his ground and refuse to extend even if defying an Act of Parliament to do so.

    However assuming the anti No Deal Bill gets Royal Assent next week rather than disobey the law Boris should shift course to try and get the EU to agree a technical solution for the Irish border as an alternative to the backstop in the EU Council of October 17th and then get an amended Withdrawal Agreement through the Commons (which the Brady amendment suggested it would).


    If the EU does not agree to remove the backstop from the Withdrawal Agreement then Boris should resign as PM by October 31st and take the Tories into opposition on a No Deal platform until the backstop is removed and let the Commons elect someone else as PM to extend. If they have not done so by the 31st as Lord Sumption, a Supreme Court judge said today a civil servant can sign the extension on behalf of the Government instead

    How’s that going to work when the bill says that the extension must be requested by the 19th October unless Parliament votes for no deal or a new Brexit deal?
    The Commons could vote for the Withdrawal Agreement minus the backstop
    a day or two before and Boris can tell the EU to either take it and his technical solution for the Irish border or leave it
    No he can’t because “leave it” has been made illegal. The EU will quite rightly simply ignore him.
    If the EU ignores a Commons majority for the Withdrawal Agreement minus the backstop then Boris rightly goes into Opposition on a No Deal platform until they change their mind
    Why would Johnson in Opposition be of any interest to the EU whatsoever?
    He wouldn't but he likely wins a majority at the next general election when he would be again
    And if my aunt had bollocks she’d be my uncle.
  • GallowgateGallowgate Posts: 19,072
    @HYUFD are the Tories taking Battersea on that poll?
  • GIN1138GIN1138 Posts: 20,697

    “The Conservatives are up 3 points to 35% of the vote, while the Brexit party is down 3 points to 13%. The Liberal Democrats are up 2 points to 17% while Labour is down 1 point to 25%.”

    Ah another predciiton I right - Con, Lib-Dem up (suspect SNP will be up there too) Lab and Brexit down. :D
  • nichomarnichomar Posts: 7,483
    Don’t get too carried away election in the spring we could be at war with Scotland by then
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 116,719
    edited September 2019

    @HYUFD are the Tories taking Battersea on that poll?

    Yes according to Electoral Calculus (though I think it could go LD)
  • IanB2IanB2 Posts: 47,098
    TGOHF said:

    Problem with seat calculators are they assume the Brexit party will stand in every seats - that’s far from a given.

    Only if the absence of the BXP is significantly to the advantage of another party. We had years of people assuming ukip voters were mostly ex Tories, which turned out to be wrong. I suspect that the absence of the BXP would help the Tories, but not nearly as much as some seem to think, and further a pact with the BXP could hit the Tories in remain seats - the leaflets write themselves
  • NickPalmerNickPalmer Posts: 21,267
    So Tories slightly ahead (Panelbase, Survation) or strongly ahead (Opinium, YouGov). Johnson is again showing that there's no publicity that's bad publicity? That said, his personal rating is down in all the polls.

    I don't think that we actually have much clue what the figures will be after Oct 31. But Newton-Dunn on the radio was interesting - he thinks Johnson will come up with a fudged deal that the EU will accept, and will fight an election on that basis. The problem is that it will reignite the BXP vote, and the decline in personal trust may make it difficult to hold the line.
  • WhisperingOracleWhisperingOracle Posts: 8,480
    edited September 2019
    nico67 said:

    GIN1138 said:

    nico67 said:

    Even less chance of Labour supporting an early election after the Opinium .

    They realize they only have s chance by splitting the Leave vote and must force the extension .

    I'm afraid the longer Labour continues to deny people a general election the worse their position will get before OR after Brexit is delayed.
    Once in an election I doubt voters are going to be obsessed over a few weeks delay .
    The thing is, the repetition of "chicken" for three weeks could have some traction for the tories. It's cheap and low politics, but as far Cummings is concerned, if it works, it will be done.
  • Big_G_NorthWalesBig_G_NorthWales Posts: 60,004
    edited September 2019

    Still no trace of this Con 40%+ that was predicted.

    I think the problem these polls pose for labour is they are not closing the gap when they are the main opposition. Indeed most polls show them static or dropping slightly and the local election results are appalling

    It is time for labour to recognise the damage Corbyn has created for them. Any sensible labour leader would have stood up against brexit and joined all parties on a stop brexit policy
  • DadgeDadge Posts: 2,038

    AndyJS said:

    10% Tory lead in Opinium

    Do we have the figures?
    Con 35%
    Lab 25%
    LDem 17%
    Brexit 13%
    Very easy to see 5% being squeezed from BXP to CON to get to 40% I'm predicting by end of October.
    I think we're at Peak Boris. By the end of October 5% of Tories will have switched (back) to Farage.
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 116,719
    malcolmg said:

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    If other weekend polls are similar to the Panelbase and Survation ones, Johnson is in deep, deep trouble. Big if, though.

    No he isn't, Tories plus DUP have a majority with Survation and even with Panelbase the Tories would still comfortably be largest party.

    However both pollsters tend to have higher Labour voteshare and lower LD voteshares than Yougov or Ipsos Mori for example

    https://twitter.com/Adam_IoM/status/1170374866056417280?s=20

    One net gain for the SNP strongly suggests Electoral Calculus is predicting Tory gains in Scotland. Hmmm.

    It also ignores the Labour losses in Scotland to the SNP too though
    and the even bigger Tory losses to SNP as well
    Tories will still likely have more Scottish seats than Labour in my view, even if fewer than the LDs
  • RobDRobD Posts: 58,941
    Dadge said:

    AndyJS said:

    10% Tory lead in Opinium

    Do we have the figures?
    Con 35%
    Lab 25%
    LDem 17%
    Brexit 13%
    Very easy to see 5% being squeezed from BXP to CON to get to 40% I'm predicting by end of October.
    I think we're at Peak Boris. By the end of October 5% of Tories will have switched (back) to Farage.
    Weren't we supposed to be at peak boris a few weeks ago? :)
  • malcolmgmalcolmg Posts: 41,684

    malcolmg said:

    DougSeal said:

    Scott_P said:
    Yes Stewart you did. You betrayed your party and country and colluded with the enemy before doing so.
    Also I would love to know in what capacity you have served your country that allows you to so disgracefully demean a former armed serviceman and civil servant in that way.
    Robert E. Lee was an active armed serviceman. Didn't stop him betraying his country.
    now you are away with the birds , WTF has the American Civil War got to do with brexit and our archaic machinations in our outdated shitty parliament , apart from both had lots of donkeys involved.
    It was a dismissal of the appeal to authority fallacy that was made by saying Stewart was a serviceman.

    If the SNP won a Yes referendum then during negotiations SNP MSPs in Holyrood were colluding with English MPs to obstruct Scottish independence and keep Scotland in the UK then that would be comparable.
    Philip , I have lost the plot with it all, I see only chickens and arseholes to the right and left. They are all useless and we are heading for worst possible outcome for sure.
  • Dadge said:

    AndyJS said:

    10% Tory lead in Opinium

    Do we have the figures?
    Con 35%
    Lab 25%
    LDem 17%
    Brexit 13%
    Very easy to see 5% being squeezed from BXP to CON to get to 40% I'm predicting by end of October.
    I think we're at Peak Boris. By the end of October 5% of Tories will have switched (back) to Farage.
    Not when Boris is the figurehead for Leave. Especially after Tory Conference which will be tubthumping.

    BXP are getting squeezed. Expelling Grieve and Clarke has killed them and they know it.
  • GIN1138GIN1138 Posts: 20,697
    nichomar said:

    Don’t get too carried away election in the spring we could be at war with Scotland by then

    Er... :D
  • GallowgateGallowgate Posts: 19,072

    Still no trace of this Con 40%+ that was predicted.

    I think the problem these polls pose for labour is they are not closing the gap when they are the main opposition. Indeed most polls show them static or dropping slightly and the local election results are appalling

    It is time for labour to recognise the damage Corbyn has created for them. Any sensible labour leader would have stood up against brexit and joined all parties on a stop brexit policy
    Agreed but it’s too late now. Where that leads us? Who can say.

    Probably CON taking 80% remain Battersea.
  • malcolmg said:

    malcolmg said:

    DougSeal said:

    Scott_P said:
    Yes Stewart you did. You betrayed your party and country and colluded with the enemy before doing so.
    Also I would love to know in what capacity you have served your country that allows you to so disgracefully demean a former armed serviceman and civil servant in that way.
    Robert E. Lee was an active armed serviceman. Didn't stop him betraying his country.
    now you are away with the birds , WTF has the American Civil War got to do with brexit and our archaic machinations in our outdated shitty parliament , apart from both had lots of donkeys involved.
    It was a dismissal of the appeal to authority fallacy that was made by saying Stewart was a serviceman.

    If the SNP won a Yes referendum then during negotiations SNP MSPs in Holyrood were colluding with English MPs to obstruct Scottish independence and keep Scotland in the UK then that would be comparable.
    Philip , I have lost the plot with it all, I see only chickens and arseholes to the right and left. They are all useless and we are heading for worst possible outcome for sure.
    Indeed.
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 116,719
    edited September 2019

    HYUFD said:

    “The Conservatives are up 3 points to 35% of the vote, while the Brexit party is down 3 points to 13%. The Liberal Democrats are up 2 points to 17% while Labour is down 1 point to 25%.”

    Electoral Calculus gives a Tory landslide and a Tory majority of 104 with this evening's Opinium.

    Tories 377
    Labour 184
    LDs 32

    Biggest Tory win since Thatcher for Boris if true

    https://www.electoralcalculus.co.uk/cgi-bin/usercode.py?CON=35&LAB=25&LIB=17&Brexit=14&Green=3&UKIP=1&TVCON=&TVLAB=&TVLIB=&TVBrexit=&TVGreen=&TVUKIP=&SCOTCON=&SCOTLAB=&SCOTLIB=&SCOTBrexit=&SCOTGreen=&SCOTUKIP=&SCOTNAT=&display=AllChanged&regorseat=(none)&boundary=2017base

    Tory gains in Scotland at the SNP’s expense again!!!

    Even if the Tories lost all 13 Scottish seats to the SNP they would still have a majority of 78 with Opinium according to Electoral Calculus
  • nico67nico67 Posts: 4,502
    Apparently another MP is heading towards the Lib Dems .

    My guess would be Heidi Allen .
  • AndrewAndrew Posts: 2,900


    I do find this somewhat amusing. The no deal act mandated the 'Kinnock' amendment is brought back. It is being supported by Stephen Kinnock and Rory Stewart and is TM WDA with adjustments agreed between labour and TM prior to her resignation

    It has a considerable number of cross party supporters including Norman Lamb as far as I am aware


    It's different - the Brady amendment was WA minus backstop. Kinnock amendment is WA inc backstop and customs union as well, so there would be a hefty Con rebellion more than wiping out any backbench opposition support.
  • nichomarnichomar Posts: 7,483
    GIN1138 said:

    nichomar said:

    Don’t get too carried away election in the spring we could be at war with Scotland by then

    Er... :D
    Events dear boy😀
  • FloaterFloater Posts: 14,195
    GIN1138 said:

    nichomar said:

    Don’t get too carried away election in the spring we could be at war with Scotland by then

    Er... :D
    Incoming turnips!!!!!
  • GallowgateGallowgate Posts: 19,072
    nico67 said:

    Apparently another MP is heading towards the Lib Dems .

    My guess would be Heidi Allen .

    That was trailed a few days ago. They also mentioned Angela Smith which would be... Brave.
  • DadgeDadge Posts: 2,038
    Byronic said:

    IANAL but it looks to me like the Rebel Alliance have committed treason felony, according to the Act of 1848, which makes it a crime to “wage war against the sovereign” - by word, deed or act - “in order to put any force or constraint upon or in order to intimidate or overawe both Houses or either House of Parliament.”

    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treason_Felony_Act_1848

    If we’re going to lock up the Prime Minister on the basis of a strange new law thrown together last week, then we definitely need to jail the Rebel Alliance on the basis of a fundamental law, which has been in force since the mid 19th century.

    Surely you realise that if you write posts like this, then everyone can see you're a nutter?
  • stodgestodge Posts: 12,745


    No. All this because MPs forgot they were delegated to represent their constituents and not their own personal wishes and desires.

    I know you all love to quote Burke on this as if he is some sort of prophet but it is worth remembering that Burke's actions based on his own philosophy ruined the businesses and lives of many of those he represented and led to him being thrown out of office 2 years later.

    In the end you can make all these claims about 'delegates' rather than 'representatives' but most of the time it is just a smoke screen for MPs doing what they want and sod their constituents.

    I was actually quoting Churchill, not Burke but that doesn't matter much.

    To be honest, MPs, once elected, can do whatever they like and it's really only their Party that keeps them "in check" via the power of the Whip.

    A referendum is not an election - my area, Newham, voted 53-47 to Remain and my MP, Stephen Timms, voted against the invoking of A50 etc. He was representing his constituents and the result of the referendum in his area if not nationally but the 47% who voted Leave in Newham aren't represented at all.

    Referenda are ultimately divisive and counter-productive and, apart from local issues, probably don't work in a parliamentary democracy. Clement Attlee saw their dangers as have others.

    The nation has had to endure this pain because the Conservative Party was unable to resolve its own internal divisions and decided asking the public would somehow lead to a resolution.
  • malcolmgmalcolmg Posts: 41,684
    HYUFD said:

    malcolmg said:

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    If other weekend polls are similar to the Panelbase and Survation ones, Johnson is in deep, deep trouble. Big if, though.

    No he isn't, Tories plus DUP have a majority with Survation and even with Panelbase the Tories would still comfortably be largest party.

    However both pollsters tend to have higher Labour voteshare and lower LD voteshares than Yougov or Ipsos Mori for example

    https://twitter.com/Adam_IoM/status/1170374866056417280?s=20

    One net gain for the SNP strongly suggests Electoral Calculus is predicting Tory gains in Scotland. Hmmm.

    It also ignores the Labour losses in Scotland to the SNP too though
    and the even bigger Tory losses to SNP as well
    Tories will still likely have more Scottish seats than Labour in my view, even if fewer than the LDs
    two is not a good result
  • dyedwooliedyedwoolie Posts: 7,786
    nico67 said:

    Apparently another MP is heading towards the Lib Dems .

    My guess would be Heidi Allen .

    The rumour is Angela Smith then Heidi at conference
  • FloaterFloater Posts: 14,195
    nico67 said:

    GIN1138 said:

    nico67 said:

    Even less chance of Labour supporting an early election after the Opinium .

    They realize they only have s chance by splitting the Leave vote and must force the extension .

    I'm afraid the longer Labour continues to deny people a general election the worse their position will get before OR after Brexit is delayed.
    Once in an election I doubt voters are going to be obsessed over a few weeks delay .
    You keep telling yourself that
  • AndyJSAndyJS Posts: 29,395
    nico67 said:

    Apparently another MP is heading towards the Lib Dems .

    My guess would be Heidi Allen .

    She's probably the most likely. Who's leading the Independent Group now?
  • So Tories slightly ahead (Panelbase, Survation) or strongly ahead (Opinium, YouGov). Johnson is again showing that there's no publicity that's bad publicity? That said, his personal rating is down in all the polls.

    I don't think that we actually have much clue what the figures will be after Oct 31. But Newton-Dunn on the radio was interesting - he thinks Johnson will come up with a fudged deal that the EU will accept, and will fight an election on that basis. The problem is that it will reignite the BXP vote, and the decline in personal trust may make it difficult to hold the line.

    Even if the EU accept does he have the numbers in parliament for any realistic deal? Seems unlikely so will have failed to get us out do or die, and would need a clear majority post election which is odds against. Not sure the EU would be willing to play their last concession at such odds.
  • malcolmgmalcolmg Posts: 41,684
    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    “The Conservatives are up 3 points to 35% of the vote, while the Brexit party is down 3 points to 13%. The Liberal Democrats are up 2 points to 17% while Labour is down 1 point to 25%.”

    Electoral Calculus gives a Tory landslide and a Tory majority of 104 with this evening's Opinium.

    Tories 377
    Labour 184
    LDs 32

    Biggest Tory win since Thatcher for Boris if true

    https://www.electoralcalculus.co.uk/cgi-bin/usercode.py?CON=35&LAB=25&LIB=17&Brexit=14&Green=3&UKIP=1&TVCON=&TVLAB=&TVLIB=&TVBrexit=&TVGreen=&TVUKIP=&SCOTCON=&SCOTLAB=&SCOTLIB=&SCOTBrexit=&SCOTGreen=&SCOTUKIP=&SCOTNAT=&display=AllChanged&regorseat=(none)&boundary=2017base

    Tory gains in Scotland at the SNP’s expense again!!!

    Even if the Tories lost all 13 Scottish seats to the SNP they would still have a majority of 78 with Opinium according to Electoral Calculus
    You need to see a doctor
  • Andrew said:


    I do find this somewhat amusing. The no deal act mandated the 'Kinnock' amendment is brought back. It is being supported by Stephen Kinnock and Rory Stewart and is TM WDA with adjustments agreed between labour and TM prior to her resignation

    It has a considerable number of cross party supporters including Norman Lamb as far as I am aware


    It's different - the Brady amendment was WA minus backstop. Kinnock amendment is WA inc backstop and customs union as well, so there would be a hefty Con rebellion more than wiping out any backbench opposition support.
    Rebellion?

    Boris should whip against it.
  • malcolmg said:

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    If other weekend polls are similar to the Panelbase and Survation ones, Johnson is in deep, deep trouble. Big if, though.

    No he isn't, Tories plus DUP have a majority with Survation and even with Panelbase the Tories would still comfortably be largest party.

    However both pollsters tend to have higher Labour voteshare and lower LD voteshares than Yougov or Ipsos Mori for example

    https://twitter.com/Adam_IoM/status/1170374866056417280?s=20

    One net gain for the SNP strongly suggests Electoral Calculus is predicting Tory gains in Scotland. Hmmm.

    It also ignores the Labour losses in Scotland to the SNP too though
    and the even bigger Tory losses to SNP as well
    I agree with you malcolm, i cant see more than 3 to 5 Tory holds
    So do I. The conservatives will be lucky to retain 2 or 3 seats
  • nichomarnichomar Posts: 7,483

    nico67 said:

    Apparently another MP is heading towards the Lib Dems .

    My guess would be Heidi Allen .

    The rumour is Angela Smith then Heidi at conference
    Possibly sandbach as well
  • nico67nico67 Posts: 4,502

    nico67 said:

    Apparently another MP is heading towards the Lib Dems .

    My guess would be Heidi Allen .

    That was trailed a few days ago. They also mentioned Angela Smith which would be... Brave.
    If it’s one of the 21 Tory rebels that would be more noteworthy but can’t think who that would be .
  • dyedwooliedyedwoolie Posts: 7,786
    AndyJS said:

    nico67 said:

    Apparently another MP is heading towards the Lib Dems .

    My guess would be Heidi Allen .

    She's probably the most likely. Who's leading the Independent Group now?
    Shuker I think
  • malcolmgmalcolmg Posts: 41,684
    It is all too crazy even for me I am off to take strong drink.
  • nico67nico67 Posts: 4,502
    nichomar said:

    nico67 said:

    Apparently another MP is heading towards the Lib Dems .

    My guess would be Heidi Allen .

    The rumour is Angela Smith then Heidi at conference
    Possibly sandbach as well
    I can’t see that . I like her and would love to see her with the Lib Dems but can’t imagine her moving .
  • JonathanJonathan Posts: 20,901
    31% and a 3% lead. Good luck with that. Goodnight.
  • Andrew said:


    I do find this somewhat amusing. The no deal act mandated the 'Kinnock' amendment is brought back. It is being supported by Stephen Kinnock and Rory Stewart and is TM WDA with adjustments agreed between labour and TM prior to her resignation

    It has a considerable number of cross party supporters including Norman Lamb as far as I am aware


    It's different - the Brady amendment was WA minus backstop. Kinnock amendment is WA inc backstop and customs union as well, so there would be a hefty Con rebellion more than wiping out any backbench opposition support.
    Yes but the support for it is coming near tomthe extreme ERG rebels

    In the heat of the october chaos we cannot be sure of the vote. But vote there has to be
  • dyedwooliedyedwoolie Posts: 7,786

    malcolmg said:

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    If other weekend polls are similar to the Panelbase and Survation ones, Johnson is in deep, deep trouble. Big if, though.

    No he isn't, Tories plus DUP have a majority with Survation and even with Panelbase the Tories would still comfortably be largest party.

    However both pollsters tend to have higher Labour voteshare and lower LD voteshares than Yougov or Ipsos Mori for example

    https://twitter.com/Adam_IoM/status/1170374866056417280?s=20

    One net gain for the SNP strongly suggests Electoral Calculus is predicting Tory gains in Scotland. Hmmm.

    It also ignores the Labour losses in Scotland to the SNP too though
    and the even bigger Tory losses to SNP as well
    I agree with you malcolm, i cant see more than 3 to 5 Tory holds
    So do I. The conservatives will be lucky to retain 2 or 3 seats
    Berwickshire, Dumfriesshire and aberdeenshire west I have as holds and close fights in Dumfries and Galloway, Aberdeen south and banff and buchan but unlikely to hold on in these
  • ByronicByronic Posts: 3,578
    Dadge said:

    Byronic said:

    IANAL but it looks to me like the Rebel Alliance have committed treason felony, according to the Act of 1848, which makes it a crime to “wage war against the sovereign” - by word, deed or act - “in order to put any force or constraint upon or in order to intimidate or overawe both Houses or either House of Parliament.”

    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treason_Felony_Act_1848

    If we’re going to lock up the Prime Minister on the basis of a strange new law thrown together last week, then we definitely need to jail the Rebel Alliance on the basis of a fundamental law, which has been in force since the mid 19th century.

    Surely you realise that if you write posts like this, then everyone can see you're a nutter?
    You are free to call me a nutter, of course, but you’re not free to dispute the wording of the Treason Felony Act of 1848. Which, prima facie, has the ‘Rebel Alliance’ bang to rights.
  • stodgestodge Posts: 12,745
    HYUFD said:



    Even if the Tories lost all 13 Scottish seats to the SNP they would still have a majority of 78 with Opinium according to Electoral Calculus

    UNS - USE-less. There's room for Uniform National Swing in the ditch along with Boris Johnson.

  • HYUFD said:

    malcolmg said:

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    If other weekend polls are similar to the Panelbase and Survation ones, Johnson is in deep, deep trouble. Big if, though.

    No he isn't, Tories plus DUP have a majority with Survation and even with Panelbase the Tories would still comfortably be largest party.

    However both pollsters tend to have higher Labour voteshare and lower LD voteshares than Yougov or Ipsos Mori for example

    https://twitter.com/Adam_IoM/status/1170374866056417280?s=20

    One net gain for the SNP strongly suggests Electoral Calculus is predicting Tory gains in Scotland. Hmmm.

    It also ignores the Labour losses in Scotland to the SNP too though
    and the even bigger Tory losses to SNP as well
    Tories will still likely have more Scottish seats than Labour in my view, even if fewer than the LDs
    You mean 1 to 0
  • Still no trace of this Con 40%+ that was predicted.

    I think the problem these polls pose for labour is they are not closing the gap when they are the main opposition. Indeed most polls show them static or dropping slightly and the local election results are appalling

    It is time for labour to recognise the damage Corbyn has created for them. Any sensible labour leader would have stood up against brexit and joined all parties on a stop brexit policy
    Agreed but it’s too late now. Where that leads us? Who can say.

    Probably CON taking 80% remain Battersea.
    Now now.
  • AndyJSAndyJS Posts: 29,395

    AndyJS said:

    nico67 said:

    Apparently another MP is heading towards the Lib Dems .

    My guess would be Heidi Allen .

    She's probably the most likely. Who's leading the Independent Group now?
    Shuker I think
    He wins the least famous leader of a political party award.
  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 116,719

    HYUFD said:

    malcolmg said:

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    If other weekend polls are similar to the Panelbase and Survation ones, Johnson is in deep, deep trouble. Big if, though.

    No he isn't, Tories plus DUP have a majority with Survation and even with Panelbase the Tories would still comfortably be largest party.

    However both pollsters tend to have higher Labour voteshare and lower LD voteshares than Yougov or Ipsos Mori for example

    https://twitter.com/Adam_IoM/status/1170374866056417280?s=20

    One net gain for the SNP strongly suggests Electoral Calculus is predicting Tory gains in Scotland. Hmmm.

    It also ignores the Labour losses in Scotland to the SNP too though
    and the even bigger Tory losses to SNP as well
    Tories will still likely have more Scottish seats than Labour in my view, even if fewer than the LDs
    You mean 1 to 0
    No, I mean 2 or 3 to 1
  • GallowgateGallowgate Posts: 19,072
    You just know that Labour will spend more time in the coming election campaign attacking the Lib Dems than the Tories.
  • nico67nico67 Posts: 4,502
    stodge said:

    HYUFD said:



    Even if the Tories lost all 13 Scottish seats to the SNP they would still have a majority of 78 with Opinium according to Electoral Calculus

    UNS - USE-less. There's room for Uniform National Swing in the ditch along with Boris Johnson.

    OMG so funny ! Great post .
  • dyedwooliedyedwoolie Posts: 7,786
    AndyJS said:

    AndyJS said:

    nico67 said:

    Apparently another MP is heading towards the Lib Dems .

    My guess would be Heidi Allen .

    She's probably the most likely. Who's leading the Independent Group now?
    Shuker I think
    He wins the least famous leader of a political party award.
    Ooooh I dunno, the 'resurgent' SDP leaders name doesn't immediately pop into the head
  • solarflaresolarflare Posts: 3,623
    The thing with the polls is you have to remember the poll shifts lag the events, not the other way round.

  • HYUFDHYUFD Posts: 116,719
    malcolmg said:

    HYUFD said:

    malcolmg said:

    HYUFD said:

    HYUFD said:

    If other weekend polls are similar to the Panelbase and Survation ones, Johnson is in deep, deep trouble. Big if, though.

    No he isn't, Tories plus DUP have a majority with Survation and even with Panelbase the Tories would still comfortably be largest party.

    However both pollsters tend to have higher Labour voteshare and lower LD voteshares than Yougov or Ipsos Mori for example

    https://twitter.com/Adam_IoM/status/1170374866056417280?s=20

    One net gain for the SNP strongly suggests Electoral Calculus is predicting Tory gains in Scotland. Hmmm.

    It also ignores the Labour losses in Scotland to the SNP too though
    and the even bigger Tory losses to SNP as well
    Tories will still likely have more Scottish seats than Labour in my view, even if fewer than the LDs
    two is not a good result
    More than they had from 1997 to 2017 still
  • nichomarnichomar Posts: 7,483
    Sound of music tonight
This discussion has been closed.